The thread that's not about Ched Evans

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Re: Ched Evans

I read this story a few days ago and thought the evidence seemed damning.

What a stupid ****

I'm guessing McDonald was found not guilty as she agreed to go to the hotel with him?
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

Some comments from the Sheffield forum.
Perhaps due to this warning** not too outrageous

**Update: this will be reopened once the case is finished.

The jury went out around 10am, decision expected in the next few minutes
.

**Please think about what you're writing.
Should anyone step out of line, your account will be suspended


Well I for one hope when I go to Hillsborough tomorrow that our fans dont start gloating and singing about it ,,,, this goes beyond football ....... another stain on the history of Sheffield United and Sheffield football

Deserves all he's got,remember she's someones daughter.
Think all Evans goals should be wiped off.lol

The BBC says that she went to the hotel alone with MacDonald. Clearly the intention was sex. Macdonald then texted Evans to say he'd 'Got a bird'. Evans then came to the hotel room, and joined in. The assumption is that she didn't consent to Evans joining in.

Not only am I not surprised, I'm also relieved at the verdict. Having sex with somebody who is unconscious has to be rape ... end of.
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

5 Years and deserves every day of it. Reassuring to see a judge giving a footballer a proper sentence for a heinous crime
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

**Please think about what you're writing.
Should anyone step out of line, your account will be suspended

Why will you be suspending accounts MoFo and what will you consider to be out of line?
 
Re: Ched Evans

Ched Evans has completed his move from Sheffield United to Prison on a Five Year deal
 
Re: Ched Evans

Is this the first time a player has been sent down for rape? I know King was sexual assault, but most rape cases involving footballers seem to, rightly or wrongly, lead to nothing.
 
Re: Ched Evans

Having read about three different reports of this story, I don't understand how Clayton MacDonald was cleared of all charges. If this woman was in no state to consent, and he had sex with her as well, then how did he not commit rape too?
 
Re: Ched Evans

Having read about three different reports of this story, I don't understand how Clayton MacDonald was cleared of all charges. If this woman was in no state to consent, and he had sex with her as well, then how did he not commit rape too?

Because the jury considered that she had consented by going to the hotel room with him for the purpose of sex
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

I'll be there tomorrow, and I'll be very surprised if I don't hear any singing about it.
Was there any songs then Jeff or were they too tense with the score at MK going their way as that was their concern as well as beating Carlisle of course.

They left it late though I heard a bit of the commentary on Radio Sheffield and the Wednesday fans sounded as though they went bananas at the final whistle.
I was working within spitting distance this afternoon of Hillsborough and had left the area just before the late goal so did not hear it live so to speak although I heard a bit of noise around 3pm as I was walking in the hilly roads above Hillsborough.
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

This case confuses me.

1. Woman makes conscious decision to have enough drinks to affect her ability to make decisions.
2. Woman able to consent to sex with one man after said drinks.
3. Woman not able to make decision to consensual sex with another man.
4. Millionaire decides to go sloppy seconds on a pissed up slapper.

WTF.
 
Last edited:
Re: Ched Evans

Rhydal, number 2 and 3 is what I don't really understand. If she did consent to having sex with Clayton MacDonald, how was she later unable to do so with Ched Evans? I haven't read any suggestions that she was drunk by the time Evans took advantage of her, so what exactly did MacDonald not do that Evans did?
 
Re: Ched Evans

Rhydal, number 2 and 3 is what I don't really understand. If she did consent to having sex with Clayton MacDonald, how was she later unable to do so with Ched Evans? I haven't read any suggestions that she was drunk by the time Evans took advantage of her, so what exactly did MacDonald not do that Evans did?

Maybe she'd passed out by the time Evans arrived.
 
Re: Ched Evans

If she did consent to having sex with Clayton MacDonald, how was she later unable to do so with Ched Evans?

She was unconscious by the time Evans arrived, so couldn't have consented.

what exactly did MacDonald not do that Evans did?

It's really ****ing simple EAF, he had permission to put his cock inside her, Evans didn't. Therefore the jury found Evans guilty of rape.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

Championship

P Pld Pts
1Ipswich4389
2Leicester4288
3Leeds Utd4387
4Southampton4284
5West Brom4372
6Norwich City4371
7Hull City4265
8Coventry City4263
9Middlesbro4363
10Preston 4363
11Cardiff City4359
12Bristol City4358
13Sunderland4356
14Swansea City4353
15Watford4352
16Millwall4350
17Blackburn 4349
18Plymouth 4348
19QPR4347
20Stoke City4347
21Birmingham4345
22Huddersfield4344
23Sheffield W4344
24Rotherham Utd4323

Latest posts

Top