Top 10 GKs

Ashov

New Member

• Apr 17, 2004

• #1

GK
1.Cudicini
2.Howard
3.Dudek
4.Given
5.Walker
6.Schazwer(sp)
7.James
8.Robinson
9.Kirkland
10.Jaaskelienan(sp)

 

trickytrev

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #2

Ashov said:

GK
1.Cudicini
2.Howard
3.Dudek
4.Given
5.Walker
6.Schazwer(sp)
7.James
8.Robinson
9.Kirkland
10.Jaaskelienan(sp)

Click to expand...

You missed out the best keeper in the premiership- Van Der Sar

 

H

highland fox

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #3

Dean Kiely ?

 

Scowcroft

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #4

Taylor at Brum has been outstanding this season, as has Niemi at Southampton......

 

trickytrev

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #5

1. Van Der Sar
2. Cudicini
3. Niemi
4. Martyn
5. Howard
6. Taylor
7. Kirkland
8. James
9. Given
10. Walker

 

trickytrev

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #6

Sorry double post, is there a delte button?

 

rotherhamfox

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #7

1.Cudicin
2.Kirkland
3.Martyn
4.Walker
5.Niemi
6.Taylor
7.Given
8.Van der sar
9.Howard
10.Robinson

There is no way David James is getting in there, bloody awful, ive already told you the story of when he was a signing me an autograph.

 

Scowcroft

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #8

rotherhamfox said:

1.Cudicin
2.Kirkland
3.Martyn
4.Walker
5.Niemi
6.Taylor
7.Given
8.Van der sar
9.Howard
10.Robinson

There is no way David James is getting in there, bloody awful, ive already told you the story of when he was a signing me an autograph.

Click to expand...

He dropped his pen?

 

MKFox

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #9

dropped his guts?

 

Scowcroft

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #10

Dropped his mum?

 

Steven

Active Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #11

He had stone hands. :? :? 8)

 

rotherhamfox

New Member

• Apr 18, 2004

• #12

Someone shouted dont give him that pen, he'll drop it, and he did.

 

Ashov

New Member

• Apr 20, 2004

• #13

Martyn

 

Malf

New Member

• Apr 23, 2004

• #14

trickytrev said:

Ashov said:

GK
1.Cudicini
2.Howard
3.Dudek
4.Given
5.Walker
6.Schazwer(sp)
7.James
8.Robinson
9.Kirkland
10.Jaaskelienan(sp)

Click to expand...

You missed out the best keeper in the premiership- Van Der Sar

Click to expand...

Not even slightly. Cudicini walks it by a country mile

 

trickytrev

New Member

• Apr 23, 2004

• #15

Malf said:

trickytrev said:

Ashov said:

GK
1.Cudicini
2.Howard
3.Dudek
4.Given
5.Walker
6.Schazwer(sp)
7.James
8.Robinson
9.Kirkland
10.Jaaskelienan(sp)

Click to expand...

You missed out the best keeper in the premiership- Van Der Sar

Click to expand...

Not even slightly. Cudicini walks it by a country mile

Click to expand...

The two of them are a long way away from the rest of the keepers in the premiership. Van Der Sar is playing the kind of football that he did in his best years at Juve. Superb stuff.

 

Scowcroft

New Member

• Apr 23, 2004

• #16

I personally feel Van De Sar has been a bit dodgy this season........

 

T

T@F:

New Member

• Apr 25, 2004

• #17

why is kirkland in everyone's top 10.
Yes, he is a good keeper with lot's of potential but what has he proved(apart from that he can be the only permanently injured goalkeeper in the Prem)
He has done nothing in the liverpool team this season.

If and only if he can get into the liverpool side for a long stretch of time and play well, then he could merit a place in the top 10.

 

pipes

New Member

• Apr 25, 2004

• #18

yeah!!!

my thoughts are similar!

kirkland has proven nothing. living in coventry as i do, i hear all these 'cov' fans going on about him but he only played in goal for coventry for less than 1season, then he went to liverpool and has played less than 20matches for them and people are trying to say he is top class??
there is no way it would have been deserved if he had gone to euro2004, walker deserves it 100times more

kirklands dirty