I’d have Huth, he made a total difference when he came in. Evans has better calmer technique defensively. Huth probably couldn’t get away with some of the man handling these days, but he was a threat off every set piece and corner.Who do you have above him?
If you don’t remember how shit Morgan could be without Huth you’re doing Bobby a disservice. Morgan looked totally composed with Huth next to him, and was frequently wearing roller skates without.Huth and Elliott are the best in my mind, but Elliott maybe my distorted child memory.
Evans is brilliant though and is certainly in the mix. A big argument for Evans vs Huth too is that Evans has basically always done it as our only senior centre back - and Maguire, Soyuncu, Fofana have all looked very good next to him and usually are the ones to take the plaudits but we've seen none are as good when Evans isn't there. As well as often also an inexperienced fullback (Chilwell, JJ, Thomas)
Huth had Morgan with him and Fuchs too - very experienced players, whereas Evans is also coaching on the pitch.
Actually disagree on that one. They were both pretty good footballers. I remember Walshy smacking left-footers into the channel for Joachim on many occasions.Or the pass to Nacho for the winning goal.
|5||West Ham Utd||34||58|