No place for McCarthy

[Lboro fox]

http://news.bbc.co.uk/sport1/hi/football/internationals/5378248.stm

McCarthy very unlucky to make it into the Ireland squad IMO, has been playing well at this level for a season longer than Ledger or Mcshane, goes to show we are officially less fashionable than Preston!!!

 

[Scarby]

i agree.

Paddy deserves at least a run out.

has he been capped before?

 

[MHS]

He'll be there soon.

 

[Melton Fox]

He'll be there soon.

They won't cap a 3rd division player

 

[alex]

He'll be their Captain one day.

 

[Lboro fox]

He'll be their Captain one day.

I would have thought he was ahead of Mcshane Ledger though.

 

[Melton Fox]

Lets not look blinkered at this. As a captain he has steered this ship close to relegation. I wouldn't pick him on track record

 

[alex]

Lets not look blinkered at this. As a captain he has steered this ship close to relegation. I wouldn't pick him on track record

No he hasn't - I don't think much criticism can be lodged on our defence this term.

 

[Melton Fox]

No he hasn't - I don't think much criticism can be lodged on our defence this term.

No, defense has been solid. So pick him as a defender, I think he's a shit cappytan

 

[alex]

Fair enough.

 

[Hazzman]

I thought McCarthy is captain of the U21s.

 

[pds]

Not good enough in my opinion.

 

[Scarby]

Not good enough in my opinion.

but surely better than Ledger or Mcshane who have been picked

 

[pds]

but surely better than Ledger or Mcshane who have been picked

Why?

 

[homer]

but surely better than Ledger or Mcshane who have been picked

Not for me he isn't

 

[Profondo Rosso]

It seems the Ireland manager has more sense than most

 

[Lboro fox]

Of all the areas that deserve criticism i didnt realise the defence was one of them!!!

Some people are never fecking happy with anything!!!

 

[pds]

Of all the areas that deserve criticism i didnt realise the defence was one of them!!!

Some people are never fecking happy with anything!!!

I am not moaning about the defence as a whole. Your right they have done ok. But I think McCarthy is very over rated and is very prone to mistake. I have thought this since we signed him.

 

[Profondo Rosso]

I am not moaning about the defence as a whole. Your right they have done ok. But I think McCarthy is very over rated and is very prone to mistake. I have thought this since we signed him.

Finally, someone who agrees with me

 

[Hazzman]

I am not moaning about the defence as a whole. Your right they have done ok. But I think McCarthy is very over rated and is very prone to mistake. I have thought this since we signed him.

Prone to a mistake, he hasnt made this season. Hes a worker and young. Better than Dublin and Keown who came here and made mistakes and didnt try to improve or do better.

No need to moan, hes done nothing wrong this season.

Then again I hate Kenton, hes rank.