Birmingham Player Ratings

[Nottingham Fox]

Logan: 5 - Had fck all to do 2nd half, didn't fill me with confidence 1st half.

Stearman: 5 - Nothing special
Johansson: 6 - Did ok, played out of position
Kisnorbo: 6 - Was the usual solid self at the back
Maybury: 1 - Not fit to where the shirt. If I performed my job like he does his, I would expect to be sacked.

Newton: 6 - Got lucky with the deflected goal, was our best player in the 2nd half IMO
Wesolowski: 5 - Pretty quiet all game
Jarrett: 4 - He's poor
Mattock: 6 - Was asked to do a job, and he think he did it well.

Hume: 6 - Tries too hard at times, didn't have luck on his side.
Fryatt: 4 - At an all time low. Will he bounce back ??

Subs: I thought they all did ok. Horsfield was a menace when he came on, held the ball well, and won us the free kicks.

 

[MHS]

The Crowd - 10
Cornish pasty - 8
Chicken Balti pie - 8
Bovril - 8
Sore Throat - 1

 

[homer]

Logan 3
Stearman 6
Johnasson 3
Kisnorbo 6
Maybury 0 (and that's being generous)
Newton 8
Jarrett 3
Weso 6
Mattock 7
Hume 6
Fryatt 2

Caddy 7
Hughes 7
Horsfield 7.5

 

[Jeff]

Two callers on 5 live last night said Fryatt was the only player who was any good last night and they couldn't understand why he was subbed.

 

[MHS]

Two callers on 5 live last night said Fryatt was the only player who was any good last night and they couldn't understand why he was subbed.

He wasn't as good as most of our players last night! He struggled in the physical battle against Jaidi, N'Gotty and Taylor.

 

[highland fox]

He wasn't as good as most of our players last night! He struggled in the physical battle against Jaidi, N'Gotty and Taylor.

If you bang the ball up to him in the air then he's going to against them

 

[homer]

If you bang the ball up to him in the air then he's going to against them

He also played like a tool

Horsfield should start on Saturday

 

[Matt_B]

please, lcfc-ratings.co.uk, you know it makes sense!

 

[SJN-Fox]

I think it's hard to mark individuals, because (apart from the first half), with one exception (and you know who you are Maybury), they fought as a team, everyone pulling together , some good passing, but if I had to earmark individuals, I thought Newton played a blinder and got his reward with a goal, Mattock was thrown in at the deep end and was exceptional, I just wish he hadn't have nicked the ball from Caddy's foot just before the end, could have been a different result, but that's what you get with a player of his age, he'll learn from it and become a better player. The subs came on and got stuck in. All credit to Worthy for trying to shake it up.

 

[Muzzy's Right Boot]

Logan - 5 - Didn't have a huge amount to do and looked shaky when he had to do that!!

Maybury - 0 - Absolute wanker, it actually looks as though he's playing bad on purpose, nobody can be that bad surely!!
Kisnorbo - 6 - Alright, not great
Johannson - 6 - Did ok bear in mind he was out of position
Stearman - 6.5 - Got better as the game went on

Mattock - 7 - Played well, 16 years old and showed fight and desire like a load of them have not all season
Jarrett - 5 - Crap again, Rubbish with the ball - not ideal for a centre mid
Weso - 6 - Not as good as Saturday but tried hard
Newton - 1st half 6 2nd half 9 - Really went for it near the end

Fryatt - 5 - Nothing is happening for him, Looks a shadow of his former self!
Hume - 6 - Tries too hard sometimes, Never in position, either on wing or somewhere in midfield

SUBS

Danny C - 7 - Thought he looked pretty sharp when he came on
Horse - 7 - Put himself about well, looked a menace, if only he could do that everyweek and not just against brum
Hughes - 7 - Not a massive fan of his at all but to be fair he did do ok when he came on

 

[No.6 Muzzy Izzet...]

Logan - 5 - Didn't have a huge amount to do and looked shaky when he had to do that!!

Maybury - 0 - Absolute wanker, it actually looks as though he's playing bad on purpose, nobody can be that bad surely!!
Kisnorbo - 6 - Alright, not great
Johannson - 6 - Did ok bear in mind he was out of position
Stearman - 6.5 - Got better as the game went on

Mattock - 7 - Played well, 16 years old and showed fight and desire like a load of them have not all season
Jarrett - 5 - Crap again, Rubbish with the ball - not ideal for a centre mid
Weso - 6 - Not as good as Saturday but tried hard
Newton - 1st half 6 2nd half 9 - Really went for it near the end

Fryatt - 5 - Nothing is happening for him, Looks a shadow of his former self!
Hume - 6 - Tries to hard sometimes, Never in position, either on wing or somewhere in midfield

SUBS

Danny C - 7 - Thought he looked pretty sharp when he came on
Horse - 7 - Put himself about well, looked a menace, if only he could do that everyweek and not just against brum
Hughes - 7 - Not a massive fan of his at all but to be fair he did do ok when he came on

I agree with that, except Jasper Jarrett. He was non-existant.

 

[muzzy magic]

Logan 3....was at fault for first goal and his kicking was terrible

Maybury 0..... i've given up even rating him now
Kisnorbo 6..... Pretty solid
Johansson 5
Stearman 5.... he's a lot better than this, we've all seen it. we need the old Stearman back for the last 3 games

Mattock...first half 5 thought he struggled...second half 7..looked quality and wasn't affraid to take people on
Weso 6...like a little pittbull, closed down well
Crab 3.... as his name suggests all the did was pass sideways....get rid!
Newton...first half 4... second half 7 battled for everything, good passing and a few good runs

Fryatt 5...looked gutted to be taken off and TBH he wasn't getting the service
Hume 6...plenty of running around without the end result


Caddy 6... f**k knows why he went to Donny we need someone like this in the team

Hughes 6 .... Well done (maybury take note) i've not been a great fan over the recent months but when he came on he showed a bit of passion and wasn't affraid to get stuck in with his twiglet legs

Horsefield 6 ....certainly wins a few freekicks a dangerous areas but he tended to drift out to the touch line instead of mixing it up in the box, he does need to start on sat though for his phyical presence

 

[newtonfox]

Logan 3....was at fault for first goal and his kicking was terrible

Maybury 0..... i've given up even rating him now
Kisnorbo 6..... Pretty solid
Johansson 5
Stearman 5.... he's a lot better than this, we've all seen it. we need the old Stearman back for the last 3 games

Mattock...first half 5 thought he struggled...second half 7..looked quality and wasn't affraid to take people on
Weso 6...like a little pittbull, closed down well
Crab 3.... as his name suggests all the did was pass sideways....get rid!
Newton...first half 4... second half 7 battled for everything, good passing and a few good runs

Fryatt 5...looked gutted to be taken off and TBH he wasn't getting the service
Hume 6...plenty of running around without the end result


Caddy 6... f**k knows why he went to Donny we need someone like this in the team

Hughes 6 .... Well done (maybury take note) i've not been a great fan over the recent months but when he came on he showed a bit of passion and wasn't affraid to get stuck in with his twiglet legs

Horsefield 6 ....certainly wins a few freekicks a dangerous areas but he tended to drift out to the touch line instead of mixing it up in the box, he does need to start on sat though for his phyical presence

that about sums it up for me

the fans gave 110% last night

 

[stevewalshwasgod]

Nils is a centre half and therfore wasnt out of position!

 

[stoneparkfoxs]

logan-4 -not great but is hendo any better!
maybury-2 -blames others for his constant mistakes!
kisnorbo-6 -average hope he stays though!
nissa-6 was not out of position he is a centre half, did ok! speed isnt everything! (sheringham!)
stears-5 not sure still about him!
mattock-6 did well!
newts-6 good goal
jarrett-5 ok
fryatt-5 we need goals
hume-5 "------------"

caddy-5 ok
hughes-5 ok
horse-4 keep us up then go away

 

[stevewalshwasgod]

logan-4 -not great but is hendo any better!
maybury-2 -blames others for his constant mistakes!
kisnorbo-6 -average hope he stays though!
nissa-6 was not out of position he is a centre half, did ok! speed isnt everything! (sheringham!)
stears-5 not sure still about him!
mattock-6 did well!
newts-6 good goal
jarrett-5 ok
fryatt-5 we need goals
hume-5 "------------"

caddy-5 ok
hughes-5 ok
horse-4 keep us up then go away

thanks for backing me up!

 

[Jeff]

nissa-6 was not out of position he is a centre half, did ok!

Second goal was his fault. He knew Cole was too quick for him so tried to foul him, but made a poor attempt at pulling him back.

 

[stevewalshwasgod]

Second goal was his fault. He knew Cole was too quick for him so tried to foul him, but made a poor attempt at pulling him back.

caught out for pace by a 34 year old:icon_lol:

 

[Matt_B]

There was still no need for Logan to go rushing out for it though

 

[stevewalshwasgod]

There was still no need for Logan to go rushing out for it though

yeah hes been a bit nervous in the last two games, what has Hendo done wrong?:icon_conf