Matt Mills Stats

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.
How does blocking the ball have anything to do with distribution?

Sometimes Mills does have a tendancy to launch the ball long straight to the opposition, and maybe he does give the ball away more than Bamba. However, Bamba loses the ball in more dangerous positions (normally edge of our own box).

Dont get me wrong I think Sol Bamba is a good defender, and I have said before I think Mills and Bamba make a decent pairing. I just dont think the gulf in class that some suggests exist between Bamba and Mills is true. The only difference is one has a song and the other doesnt.

Both of them have a song.

I agree there isn't much of a gulf in class, but it doesn't matter where they give it away on the pitch if they win the ball back, if a player makes a mistake at the edge of his own area but then wins the ball back, that is much better defending than a player who makes a great sliding challenge to win the ball but then passes it straight back to the opposition.

Like you I think they're both decent players and make a decent pairing, still not sure they are either individual players or a pairing who are good enough to get us promoted though.
 
Last edited:
Both of them have a song.

I agree there isn't much of a gulf in class, but it doesn't matter where they give it away on the pitch if they win the ball back, if a player makes a mistake at the edge of his own area but then wins the ball back, that is much better defending than a player who makes a great sliding challenge to win the ball but then passes it straight back to the opposition.

Like you I think they're both decent players and make a decent pairing, still not sure they are either individual players or a pairing who are good enough to get us promoted though.

Mills has a song?

The only reason I am sticking up for Mills is because I see what he does for the team. At recent games I have had to put up with fans constantly moaning about him. I therefore started to loudly comment everytime he won a tackle/block and they soon start to stack up. So much so that the moaning fans seemed to shut up...now they just complain about Beckford.

On a different point it will be interesting if Bamba gets back into the team once he comes back from African Cup. Assuming Mills and Tunch stay fully fit.
 
Last edited:
Mills has a song?

The only reason I am sticking up for Mills is because I see what he does for the team. At recent games I have had to put up with fans constantly moaning about him. I therefore started to loudly comment everytime he won a tackle/block and they soon start to stack up. So much so that the moaning fans seemed to shut up...now they just complain about Beckford.

On a different point it will be interesting if Bamba gets back into the team once he comes back from African Cup. Assuming Mills and Tunch stay fully fit.


Yes, the Mills' song is the same as the Steve Walsh/Jack Hobbs song.

I'm not doubting Mills doesn't do his part but defending is not all about putting in blocks and tackles or winning the ball in the air, in fact in the modern game, it's very little about that. It's about keeping the ball.

A player who reads the ball well and cuts out opposition passes is a far better defender than a player who wins the ball through crunching tackles or throws himself in front of the ball making blocks as reading the game wins possession, making blocks and tackles doesn't and a defender who can't pass and is constantly gives the ball away and I never really see Mills cutting out passes and I still question his ability to read the game in that sense and distribution like his, in any position, is a hindrance on the side just as much as a player who makes constant defensive errors.

Mills does make some good tackles and blocks and wins the ball in the air (but the directing of his headers is still questionable, though not as much as Bamba's who imo is very poor at directing his headers) but his distribution and average reading of the games are what make me question whether he is really the kind of player to lead us forward.

Mentioning Tunchev, if we get the player back we saw in League One then that is what we want imo. Very good at reading the game and extremely composed in possession. Doesn't make the challenges/blocks that Mills makes, but is a far better defender. Just hope his injuries haven't ruined him.

Similarly, by what Reading fans are saying, Reading's defence is much better this season with the much more intelligent defender Kaspars Gorkss in it over Mills, despite not having the flashy blocks or tackles. Mills reminds me of Hobbs and Kisnorbo in that while he's in the team making the blocks and tackles you think he's an excellent defender, but once he's gone, you realise his game was too flawed for him to be that good.

Meh. Maybe I'm just biased because Mills isn't really my type of player, so to speak.
 
Last edited:
Mills is sound defender who perhaps needs to learn a bit of self control.

I think Mills is being racially victimised by all our Iraqi fans
 
It does seem like some of our fans Hadith in for Millsy


I'll just get me coat...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

P Pld Pts
1Liverpool1128
2Manchester C  1123
3Chelsea1119
4Arsenal1119
5Nottm F1119
6Brighton1119
7Fulham1118
8Newcastle1118
9Aston Villa1118
10Tottenham 1116
11Brentford1116
12Bournemouth1115
13Manchester U1115
14West Ham1112
15Leicester1110
16Everton1110
17Ipswich118
18Palace117
19Wolves116
20Southampton114

Latest posts

Back
Top