Player Ratings vs Brighton

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.

sheffield_fox

New Member
Ratings this week should be very interesting but to avoid a few problems that arose last week, I am only going to count votes which:
1 - are not anything ridiculous like all 1's
2 - no negative numbers

Here are mine:

Walker 6
Canero 6
Tiatto 8
Dabizas 4
Heath 3
Scowcroft 7
Stewart 5
Nalis 5
Gudjonsson 3
Connolly 4
Dublin 3

Gillespie 4
Wilcox 4
Blake 2

My comments:
Walker - should have done better on their goal
Heath - Worst game I've seen him play, looked very risky and his distribution was woeful
Tiatto - only him and scowy looked remotely interested, kept the ball brilliantly, won it back and passed it along the floor, hope he's not too injured
Gudjonsson - anonymous
Connolly & Dublin - no service but still poor
Gillespie - did a few good things but the bad outweighed the good
Blake - actually gave the ball away EVERY time he touched it

Lets see everyone's ratings please.
 
Walker 6
Canero 6
Tiatto 8
Dabizas 4
Heath 4
Scowcroft 7
Stewart 5
Nalis 6
Gudjonsson 4
Connolly 4
Dublin 3

Gillespie 4
Wilcox 4
Blake 2
 
Walker 6
Canero 6
Stewart 6
Heath 4
Dabizas 4
Scowcroft 6
Gudjonsson 4
Nalis 6
Tiatto 8
Dublin 4
Connolly 5

Gillespie 5
Blake 3
Wilcox 3
 
Walker 6
Canero 6
Heath 3
Dabizas 4
Scowcroft 6
Nalis 6
Gudjohnsson 5
Tiatto 8
Connolly 5
Dublin 3
Stewart 6

Gillespie 4
Wilcox 4
Blake 0-and thats being generous
 
Walker 5
Canero 6
Heath 5
Dabizas 5
Tiatto 7.5
Scowcroft 7
Nalis 6
Gudjohnson 4
Stewart 3
Dublin 5
Connolly 4.5

Blake 2.5
Wilcox 4
Gillespie 5
:cry: :cry:
 
Walker 5 - poor on goal, shudnt be beaten at near post fro 25 yards
Canero 6 - ok.
Tiatto 7, did ok, shame he got injured as he looked our biggest threat
Dabizas 5 - poor but never have been subbed as Heath was still on pitch.
Heath 2 - the biggest joke of a footballer I have ever seen, Keown must be pissing himself this bloke stays ahead of him.
Scowcroft 6- tried but shit
Stewart 2 - shit every game
Nalis 6 - did ok, good passes but dont expect him to play well in this team
Gudjonsson 4 - Id rather have Joey from friends on the pitch.
Connolly 4 - Really average striker.
Dublin 3 - Benjamin will be in if he carries on performing like that

Adams 0 - Go Now before we force you out. You have no clue how to select a team, no clue how to change a team and no ability to judge a player whatsoever. You are completely clueless.
 
walker 7
tiatto 8
heath 4
dabizas 3
canero 6
scowy 6
nalis 6
gudjonsson 2
jordan 2
connelly 4
dublin 3

blake 1
gillespie 3

Complete and utter drivel. Just when you thought it couldn't get any worse, that is possibly the worst performance I've ever seen. We've got no midfield, no creativity, no passion, no hope. Automatic promotion is already out of the question, best we can hope for is play offs. I can't belive I got my credit card took off us for buying a season ticket which took us over me overdraft and I have to work shocking nights to pay if off! If it doesn't change quickly Micky has to go. Next game against the bottom team. We must win then. Won't we?
 
Walker 3
Canero 6
Tiatto 8
Dabizas 4
Heath 5
Scowcroft 7
Stewart 4
Nalis 5
Gudjonsson 3
Connolly 6
Dublin 3

Gillespie 6
Wilcox 5
Blake 3
 
Walker 6
Canero 6
Tiatto 8
Dabizas 5
Heath 6
Scowcroft 6
Stewart 3
Nalis 5
Gudjonsson 4
Connolly 6
Dublin 3

Gillespie 5
Wilcox 5
Blake 2
 
Walker 6
Canero 6
Tiatto- 9
Dabizas- 4
Heath- 4
Scowcroft- 6
Stewart- 5
Nalis- 6
Gudjonsson- 4
Connolly- 5
Dublin- 4

Gillespie- 6
Wilcox- 5
Blake- 3

Adams- P45
 
Walker 4
Canero 6
Tiatto 8
Dabizas 5
Heath 4
Scowcroft 5
Stewart 5
Nalis 7
Gudjonsson 4
Connolly 4
Dublin 3

Gillespie 4
Wilcox 4
Blake 2

What a mess
 
walker 6
canero 6
heath 5
dabizas 5
stewart 3
scowcroft 5
nalis 5
gudjohnson 5
tiatto 7
dublin 4
connolly 5

wilcox 2
gillespie 6
blake 5
 
Real ratings

Walker 0 (only thing he had to do was get the ball out of the net)
Canero 0
Tiatto 5
Dabizas 0
Heath 0
Scowcroft -1 (awful foul)
Stewart 0 (couple of good runs down the wing but lost his point with his dreadful distribution)
Nalis 1 (at least he had a shot or 2)
Gudjonsson -1 (why was he there?)
Connolly 1 (tried a bit)
Dublin 0 (striker?)

total
5 out of 110
tossers
 
walker 6
Canero 6
Dabizas 5
Heath 4
Stewart 6
Scowcroft 6
Nalis 5
Gudjohnsen 5
Tiatto 8
Dublin 4
Connelly 5

Wilcox 5
Blake 3
Gillespie 6
 
Walker - 6
Canero - 4
Tiatto - 8
Dabizas - 3
Heath -3
Scowcroft -6
Stewart -5
Nalis -4
Gudjonsson -4
Connolly - 1
Dublin -2

Gillespie -2
Wilcox -1
Blake - 1

Sorry about the ones but I feel they are deserved - I didn't even see some of these players on the ball! Also they are not minus's just hypohons --
 
Tiatto 10
Gillespie 6.5

All the others 0.

Adams needs to sort this mess out pronto. There is more potency in a panda than our attack and they are an endangered species! :x :wink:
 
walker 6-partly at fault for goal, no communication with defence at times
Canero 6- looked ok
Heath 5-looked unsure at times, a few passes went astray
dabizas 4-should be a wrestler not a defender
stewart 2-more accuracy in a one armed archer, he gets PAID to do this!!
Scowcroft 6-tried hard for a few minutes then was non-existant
Nalis 6-did sum good stuff, unluck to see a good effort go wide
Gudjonnson 5-left big holes in midfeild, wasn't effective a a DM
Tiatto 9- Great performance, had drive and hunger, looked composed too.
Dublin 3-missed a sitter, wouldnt trust him in defence either
Connolly 4- didnt get into the game, has talent but wasted at a hoofer club

Gillespie 6- sum nice runs but no end product,looks to be getting more interested
wilkox 5- more bad passing and no ideas
Blake- deary me, reactions of a dog and doesnt look to have any ability.
 
i don't understand how walker has earnt any points at all? they don't just start on 6 for turning up?
sorry for singling out walker, applies to 9 today..
 
I personally do my ratings comparible to championship manager where they start on a 5 and go from there, the less or the worse they do, they go down, the better things they do, they go up.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

Championship

P Pld Pts
1Leicester4597
2Ipswich4593
3Leeds Utd4590
4Southampton4584
5Norwich City4573
6West Brom4572
7Hull City4570
8Middlesbro4566
9Coventry City4564
10Preston 4563
11Bristol City4562
12Cardiff City4562
13Swansea City4557
14Watford4556
15Sunderland4556
16Millwall4556
17QPR4553
18Stoke City4553
19Blackburn 4550
20Sheffield W4550
21Plymouth 4548
22Birmingham4547
23Huddersfield4545
24Rotherham Utd4524

Latest posts

Top