Player Ratings vs QPR

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.

sheffield_fox

New Member
Taylor 9
Dublin 8
Dabizas 7
Keown 7
Makin 7
Stewart 7.5
Gemmill 6
Williams 8
Nalis 6
Connolly 7.5
Scowcroft 7

Subs:
Gudjonsson 6
Tiatto 6
Heath 6
 
Taylor 9
Dublin 7.5
Dabizas 6.5
Keown 7
Makin 6.5
Stewart 8
Gemmill 6
Williams 8.5
Nalis 6
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 6.5

Subs:
Gudjonsson 6
Tiatto 6
Heath 6
 
Taylor 8
Dublin 7
Dabizas 6
Keown 7
Makin 5
Stewart 6
Gemmill 5
Williams 7
Nalis 5
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 5

Subs:
Gudjonsson 6
Tiatto 6

Don't see how you can rate Heath for the short time he was on the pitch.
 
Taylor 8
Dublin 8
Dabizas 6
Keown 6
Stewart 7
Makin 6
Gemmill 6
Williams 8
Nalis 6
Connelly 7
Scowcroft 5

Gudjonsson 7
Tiatto 6

Better performance alll round i thought, Showed a bit of fight and passion.
Happy with that.
 
Taylor 9
Dublin 8
Dabizas 6
Keown 6
Makin 6
Stewart 7
Gemmill 6
Williams 7
Nalis 6
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 7

Subs:
Gudjonsson 6
Tiatto 5
Heath 6
 
Taylor 8
Dublin 7
Dabizas 6
Keown 6
Makin 6
Stewart 8
Gemmill 6
Williams 7
Nalis 6
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 4.5

Subs:
Gudjonsson 6
Tiatto 5
Heath 6

Dublin headed well in defence today but his distribution was awful, him and scowcroft are the main 2 reasons we struggle to hold on to the ball. Connely is playing by himself for long periods of the game, hope the Norwich/Palace rumours are true.
 
Taylor 8
Makin 6
Dublin 7
Keown 7
Dabizas 6
Stewart 7

Nalis 6
Williams 8
Gemmil 5

Connolly 7
Scowcroft 6

Gudjohnson 6
Tiatto 6
Heath wasn't on long enough in my opinion
 
Taylor 7- Kicking terrible, saving brilliant
Makin 6- One of his best performances
Stewart 8- Hes learning
Dublin 6
Dabizas 5
Keown 5- He always wants to fight!
Gemmill 6- Not really on long enough
Williams 7- Looks a lot more fitter
Nalis 6
Scowcroft 6
Connolly 8- 100% again!

Subs-
Gudjonsson 3- Rubbish
Tiatto 6
Heath 6
 
Taylor 8
Makin 3
Dublin 6.5
Keown 6.8
Dabizas 5
Stewart 8

Nalis 4
Williams 9
Gemmil 2

Connolly 3
Scowcroft 1

Gudjohnson 2
Tiatto 4
Heath 4
 
Sam, do you deliberately aim to win the harshest voter award every week? You can argue with me on this one if you like but I thought Scowcroft did nothing to warrant anywhere near a one. I thought he had an excellent first half.
 
Some crazy scores on here today

Taylor 8
Makin 5
Keown 5
Dabizas 5
Dublin 6
Stewart 7
Williams 7
Nalis 5
Gemill Not on long enough
Scowcroft 5
Connolly 6

Gudjonsson 5
Tiatto 4
 
I don't think we played very well today and I think we were very lucky to come away with 3 points let alone 1. Taylor is the reason we got 3 points.
 
Taylor 8 Some cracking saves
Makin 6 Better
Dabizas 6 Still thinks he is better than he actually is!
Dublin 6.5 Some good defensive headers, but can be a bit to cool at times.
Keown 6.5
Gemmill 6
Nalis 6 Better than the Rotherham game
Williams 7 Improving all the time, needs a few more 90 minutes under his belt.
Stewart 7.5 We looked at our most threatening when he ran at their defence.
Connolly 5.5 Is he brain dead? gets a needless booking then starts kicking a defender in their area and also starts on the linesman. Gave up to easily after losing the ball.
Scowcroft 5.5 How many games have these 2 been playing together up front. Not convinced

Subs ( on for more than 15 minutes)
Gudjohnsen 6 Unlucky in the 2nd half with a shot but where were the players following up to pounce on the rebound?
Tiatto 6 all blood and guts

A game where the result was more important than the performance. yes QPR had 2 disallowed (ref had actually blown before the shot came in for the 1st). Yes we might have rode our luck, but we did have good chances of our own. Still question why everyone comes back to defend a corner or freekick, as it doesn't give us an outlay so ball keeps coming back, as we all saw today. But hey we won!!! :lol:
 
Taylor 7 - shot stopping was fantastic but his kicking was a real liability at times

Makin 6 - a decent performance, got some good balls into the box 1st half

Dublin 6 - good at the back, bad distribution
Keown 7 - showed a lot of heart and made some important challenges
Dabisaz 6 - ok

Stewart 7 - missed a great chance but looked more confident and dangerous than he has done since he 1st broke into the team

Gemmil 6 - looked ok till he went off
Nalis 5 - off the pace
Williams 6 - showed promise but needs to get into game more

Scowcroft 5 - wasnt at the races a lot of the time
Connolly 6 - looked lively at times but gets marked down for some STUPID tackles

Gudjonnson 5
Tiatto 6

basically i thought we started fantastically and would have won comfortably if we'd taken the game to them - they looked clueless in their own area - iv marked down most of the midfield for not pressing up enough but most of the side was guilty of that - it was an agonising last 75 minutes or so
 
Taylor-8 world class saves, please improve kicking
Makin-6 Good start, made up for his rest of game average performance
Stewart-7 growing in confidence, IMO was very good today
Dublin-6 solid headin, few good tackles.
Keown-6 excellent positional sense, there for the cause
Dabizas-5 ???
Gemmill-5 looked ok until was unfortunatly subbed
Williams-7 always lookin to attack, passin and movin was good
Nalis-6 drifted in and out of the game
Connolly-7 goal, commitment, effort, 100% workrate
Scowcroft-6 put himself about, beaten for pace most of the time
Joey-5 just play it simple!!
Tiatto,6 first thing he did was a foul!! gr8 comitment
 
Taylor 8 three or four great saves that somehow got us three points
Makin 5 a few good tackles, but also got done a few times, one good cross too
Dublin 8 getting the ball from Taylor and built from the back was effective
Keown 6 did well, nothing flashy, but steady
Dabizas 6 about same as Keown
Stewart 7 what a great run in the first half, looked good going forward
Gemmill 5
Williams 8 battled hard, certainly asking for a starting place next week
Nalis 7 a better game for Lil, took the chances to go forward well
Connolly 7 would have been 6, 1 for the goal. Looked tired
Scowcroft 6 don't understand how people can give him 1

Gudjonson 6 did well, didnt excel
Tiatto 5 didn't really have time to show much, got booked as well...
 
everyones entitled to their own opinion of course but some of these ratings look kind of generous considering the battering we were given for much of the game and our failure to compete in the middle of the park - i try to be as positive as possible but the fact is we let ourselves be overrun today
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

P Pld Pts
1Liverpool1128
2Manchester C  1123
3Chelsea1119
4Arsenal1119
5Nottm F1119
6Brighton1119
7Fulham1118
8Newcastle1118
9Aston Villa1118
10Tottenham 1116
11Brentford1116
12Bournemouth1115
13Manchester U1115
14West Ham1112
15Leicester1110
16Everton1110
17Ipswich118
18Palace117
19Wolves116
20Southampton114

Latest posts

Back
Top