Player Ratings vs Reading (FAC4)

[Boy Genius]

Walker 7
Maybury 8
Stewart 7
Dabizas 6
Heath 6
Gillespie 7
Tiatto 7
Gudjonsson 7
Williams 8
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 8

De Vries 7
Nalis 6
Dublin 6

Reading announced their fans as No.13 with the subs when calling the teams out, our fans were at the game playing and made brilliant noise so I give them 100 as well

 

[pipes]

Walker 7
Maybury 7
Stewart 7
Dabizas 7
Heath 7
Gillespie 6
Tiatto 7
Gudjonsson 7
Williams 8
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 8

De Vries 6
Nalis 5
Dublin 5

 

[Nottingham Fox]

Walker 7
Maybury 7
Stewart 7
Dabizas 7
Heath 6
Gillespie 6
Tiatto 7
Gudjonsson 7
Williams 7
Connolly 8
Scowcroft 7

De Vries 6
Nalis 5
Dublin 5

 

[sheffield_fox]

The deadline for ratings is 7pm. The results will be announced shortly after. The monthly awards will be announced tomorrow.

 

[Xantha]

Ok my first time rating the team...

Walker 7
Maybury 7
Heath 6
Dabizas 6
Stewart 7
Gillespie 7
Gudjonsson 7
Williams 8
Tiatto 7
Connolly 7
Scowcroft 7 - Left quite unnerved by the eye contact from him when he was celebrating his goal directly in front of me.

Subs
De Vries 6
Dublin 5
Nalis 6

 

[East Anglia Fox]

Walker 8
Maybury 7 Great buy IMO likes to get forward, very effective
Heath 8 Very good, he's just want we want, home grown and still young
Dabizas 8 Best diplay I've ever seen of him got aroound poeple very well
Stewart 6
Gillespie 6
Gudjohnssen 6
Williams 7
Tiatto 8 Not quite as good as normall I'd say but still very good.
Connolly 4
Scowcroft 6 He was pretty lazy and missed too many chances apart from the goal

Heath and Dabizas 8 but Connolly 4???? You're either taking the piss or you were sitting in the car park


my ratings.....


Walker 7
Maybury 6
Heath 5
Dabizas 5.5
Stewart 6
Gillespie 7
Gudjohnssen 6
Williams 8
Tiatto 7
Connolly 8
Scowcroft 7

OK perhaps a 5 for Connolly, but that was because of all the easy opportunities that he had and never scored. I remember saying to my brother after the match, 'if we'd had 2 strikers up front today we would have won about 5-1.'

Dabizas 5.5?????? what's the point in saying he was crap every time he playes even when he plays well? Even if you hate a player, you should rate them as if you are neutral, to make it as fair and accurate as possible. people like you might as well rate Dabizas before the ball is kicked if you're always going to rate him badly even if he makes vital tackles and clearences all the time and passes well.

 

[step]

East Anglia Fox & Semper Eadem
The whole point of this rating is to get everyones opinion and it dont matter who likes or dislikes it. Please keep this thread open minded unpressured.
Discuse the players good and bad points in another thread.

PS: Keep up the good work Shef

PPS: Have you made a million yet Shef

PPPS: You'll kick yourself one day Shef