Walker or Taylor

[Orifice]

If Ian Walker was suddenly match fit.........

Who would you choose as starting keeper?

 

[SilverFox]

In goal, Player No 1...IAN WALKER! but only marginally, and because i'm sentimental

 

[bertfox]

Walker

 

[FOX MENTAL]

Walker edges it for me. both quality kepers but i feel walker is more secure in the air!!

 

[Scodger Cubs]

Taylor no doubt about it. He's young, energetic and has been very impressive so far and i don't know why we would drop him-I doubt CL would either !!

 

[lazzer]

i think we need to see a bit more of taylor before making judgements like this :roll:

 

[homer]

i wanted to vote for Pressman

 

[Tony Elsby]

i wanted to vote for Pressman

Taylor without a doubt.

Right end of his career. Good dominant keeper.

 

[leicester_til_i_die]

i would like to see us keep taylor, because walker is coming to the end of time, but unlike most postions experience is a big factor with a keeper.

 

[lazzer]

i wanted to vote for Pressman

Taylor without a doubt.

Right end of his career. Good dominant keeper.

judge in haste repent at leisure

 

[Sam]

I've got to say it would have to be Taylor as he is bringing some new blood into the team and also Walker possibly wouldn't try if he plays again for LCFC as he doesn't want to stay at the club let alone play with this knee injury which has kept him out for so long. So it's Taylor without a doubt.

 

[MKFox]

:?
bit confused here...

thought he was just here on loan to get some first team action..
not sure Mons. Wenger is looking to sell him :?
and if he was, i doubt if we could afford him.

lazzer could still do a job between the sticks, let's face it he nearly fills the gap...

 

[LufbraFox]

Watching Arsenal tonight i think Taylor is slightly unlucky not to be getting a look in, there new spanish keeper is pish

Oh bugger, now theyre mentioning Taylor on ITV!

 

[SilverFox]

Watching Arsenal tonight i think Taylor is slightly unlucky not to be getting a look in, there new spanish keeper is pish

Oh bugger, now theyre mentioning Taylor on ITV!

Yeah that made me gulp as well!

We must understand however, that this is a LOAN deal! We cannot afford this player! no chance! I hope I am proven wrong, but I highly doubt it

 

[Foxes_Never_Quit]

#1 Ian Walker

 

[Steven]

Isn't there some keeper at Hearts that CL is supposed to be bringing here as soon as :?:

 

[chrislcfc18]

What you have to remember is if CL does bring in a new keeper, whether it be Taylor or whoever, then neither Walker nor the new keeper will be happy sitting on the bench every week. Certainly not Walker anyway.

This must be one the most difficult selection headaches a manger can have.

 

[levinwong]

taylor, until he makes a mistake

walker is too flop-prone

taylor is only here on loan, lets get the most out of him

 

[Fox Fan]

taylor, until he makes a mistake

walker is too flop-prone

taylor is only here on loan, lets get the most out of him

That post was stupid!

Every Keeper in history has made mistakes :roll:

Yeah he's here on loan, doesn't mean you should drop your No1 keeper for him :roll:

I'd also like to point out its pesimistic people like you that drag this club down!

 

[Steven]

taylor, until he makes a mistake

walker is too flop-prone

taylor is only here on loan, lets get the most out of him

Great post. It could be that Taylor does not make a serious mistake and Walker's tenure as No. 1 is hanging by a thread. I hope Taylor is more than a loan, but I leave that up to CL.