I’m not as pessimistic as many on here after what I saw last night, there were some positives. Nndi stood out & Nacho looked very good too & was oozing confidence with clever flicks, general play & of course his goal.
Maddison did not disappoint & was busy & creative. BUT the defence is definitely a cause for concern. Whilst the short-comings of Benny & Morgan are well-known, in my opinion Chillwell for all his promise & potential is also (currently) still a liability. Inside 15 minutes from kick off he gave the ball away twice in very dangerous positions. I’m sure that in the PL both would’ve resulted in a goal. It looks to me as if Puel has Chillwell ahead of Fuchs which I think is a big mistake. Yes Fuchs is slow, but he’s more solid & less prone to fatal errors than Chilwell. He’s a wily old Fox & more reliable.
The new right back looked ok & there was a particularly sweet attack in the 2nd half involving him & (if memory serves me right), Albrighton.
Bringing on all the kids in the last half an hour was interesting & a chance to make something of themselves.
Darnell Johnson at centre back immediately caught the eye & just simply looked the part. This kid will be great & we must keep him, I heard that he may leave. Even so, I don’t think any manager would throw him in at Old Trafford I’m afraid we’re stuck with ‘experience’ so that means Benny at Old Trafford.
Of the other kids who came on, (apologies for not remembering names & this will only mean something to those who were there), the no.19 & 37 looked promising to me with confidence in themselves that didn’t look misplaced. The right winger however looked too slow & the left winger wearing no.4 was involved a lot without making that much of an impact. He might be one for the future but as I said, 19 & 37 looked exciting prospects to me.
What else? Amarty looked assured & a very able deputy for the new right back. Albrighton was decent seemed to be helping his right back too much in the first half but attacked well in the 2nd half until he made way for the youngsters to have a go.
Ibbora disappointed me in the first half, looked marginally better in the 2nd when he had more responsibility following the substitution of Nndi, though he too soon was substituted.
Silver tried very hard when he came on & was very involved. Looks to be behind Ibora in Puels pecking order (it’s a given that Nndi is one of the 1st names on the team sheet) but I think if Ibora doesn’t step up to the plate & up his game Silva can & should replace him. Cover for injury as well.
Unfortunately even if the attack and the midfield are good, it’s (literally) pointless if we have Chilwell making fatal errors & Morgan losing his man most of the time. For Utd of course we have the absurdly delicious prospect of them being joined by Benny.
Shame about the last facts above because there are some VERY good players in that team and some very exciting youngsters knocking at the door too.