Plymouth Argyle player ratings

[MHS]

Logan 6
Maybury 6
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 5
Sylla 7
Stearman 6
Hughes 5
Welsh 5
Fryatt 6
Hume 7

Porter 6

 

[Boy Genius]

Logan 7
Maybury 6
McCarthy 7
Kisnorbo 7
Johansson 7
Sylla 7
Stearman 5
Hughes 3
Welsh 3
Fryatt 3
Hume 8

Porter 6

 

[Melton Fox]

Logan 6
Maybury 4
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 4
Sylla 6
Stearman 4
Hughes 2
Welsh 2
Fryatt 5
Hume 7

Porter 3

 

[Scarby]

from the radio

Logan 6
Maybury 5
McCarthy 6
Kisnorbo 7
Johansson 6
Sylla 8
Stearman 5
Hughes 6
Welsh 5
Fryatt 6
Hume 8

Porter 6/7

 

[Lako42]

Logan 6
Maybury 4
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 3
Sylla 6
Stearman 4 what do you expect from a defender? still better than the experienced midfielder that is AJ which says something
Hughes 0 who and where?
Welsh 0 awfull display
Fryatt 3 offered nothing, partly because of the shit service
Hume 8

Porter 4

 

[Tamworth Fox]

Logan 6
Maybury 7
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 5
Johansson 5
Sylla 8
Stearman 5
Hughes 6- (motm first half second half (85mins) he was poor)
Welsh 3
Fryatt 4
Hume 8 MOTM

Porter 7

 

[Boy Genius]

Logan 6
Maybury 4
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 3
Sylla 6
Stearman 4 what do you expect from a defender? still better than the experienced midfielder that is AJ which says something
Hughes 0 who and where?
Welsh 0 awfull display
Fryatt 3 offered nothing, partly because of the shit service
Hume 8

Porter 4

but Fryatt offers nothing anyway, he is turning into another lazy sod who thinks he is better than the rest.... Shit service to him is not a good enough excuse for him IMO. Maybe he will feck off after xmas

 

[Durham Fox]

Some massively harsh scores for paddy m, thought he was our man of the match today.

 

[Lako42]

to be honest, the magic of fryatt has gone for me too. he isnt as good as hume. hume had no service but he made things for himself because he works his arse off. i cant help thinking matty fryatt thinks he's better than he is.

 

[Scarby]

Is Fryatt fully fit yet?

 

[newtonfox]

Some massively harsh scores for paddy m, thought he was our man of the match today.

i must admit your right paddy headed the ball first half and gradded his face mask not sure if its done anything to his eye but in one way im glad he's had his 5th yellow to give him time to heal a bit

 

[Hazzman]

Is Fryatt fully fit yet?

Not on today's standards, Fryatt does not get the correct service, big balls in the air are not going to help your goal poacher. Hume will run for everything and work hard, hes a support striker.


Logan 5

Maybury 3
Johansson 6
Kisnorbo 6
McCarthy 6

Sylla 7
Welsh 4
Hughes 5
Stearman 5 'Be a passenger....'

Hume 8
Fryatt 6

Porter 5 Nice finish tho

 

[fcukcov]

i must admit your right paddy headed the ball first half and gradded his face mask not sure if its done anything to his eye but in one way im glad he's had his 5th yellow to give him time to heal a bit

Have to agree MOM today for me to.

Glad everyone rated sylla highly he didnt do bad to day, looked a little off the pace at times but then that could be said for most of the team tbh. At least you lot are not like the twat that sat near me that blamed sylla for everything that didnt end with the ball in the back of the net. He told sylla he was shit when he didnt reach a pass superman would of struggled to get to before the argyle defender. Mind you this lad summed himself up when he went "wow, if we had sheehan and mcauley playing instead of kisnorbo and johanson we would have an all irish defence!" TWAT.

 

[East Anglia Fox]

Yeah I thought Sylla showed a real improvement today. I thought he played really well. I'd give him 8/10. He did a lot of good heading, his running between players was very impressive, not what we normally see these days. I thought only a few weeks ago that his Leicester career was over but he has really proved to RK (hopefully) that he deserved a permenant place in the team. Well done Momo

 

[Lako42]

Yeah I thought Sylla showed a real improvement today. I thought he played really well. I'd give him 8/10. He did a lot of good heading, his running between players was very impressive, not what we normally see these days. I thought only a few weeks ago that his Leicester career was over but he has really proved to RK (hopefully) that he deserved a permenant place in the team. Well done Momo

lets not get carried away, he is still one of the worst players ive ever seen. and thats judging all of his performances.

 

[pds]

Logan 6
Maybury 7
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 4
Sylla 7
Stearman 6
Hughes 5
Welsh 3
Fryatt 3
Hume 9

Porter 6

 

[Melton Fox]

Logan 6
Maybury 7
McCarthy 5
Kisnorbo 6
Johansson 4
Sylla 7
Stearman 6
Hughes 5
Welsh 3
Fryatt 3
Hume 9

Porter 6

 

[newtonfox]

6 at the most he did do ok

 

[Leigh]

Again surprised by the ratings for Hughes, but I suppose it's hard to change mass opinion. Thought he had an ok game, one of the best players in the 1st half, best chance on goal next to the goal, good ball to put Fryatt through at one point, switched the play, even put in a few tackles! Second half he faded, still not convinced he's fully fit. For the rest of them

Logan - 5
Maybury - 5
McCarthy - 7
Kisnorbo - 7
Johansson - 5 (for the arse control)
Sylla - 5
Hughes - 6
Stearman - 6
Welsh - 4
Hume - 8
Fryatt - 6 (is he a seal?)

Subs:
Porter - 6 (for the goal)

 

[highland fox]

lets not get carried away, he is still one of the worst players ive ever seen. and thats judging all of his performances.

I tend to agree,the only plus point for him is that he is a right winger and not a converted Right Back,Central Midfielder etc.However he will let you down and piss you off you just know it