Why Leicester sacked Brendan Rodgers – player unrest, split fanbase and facing relegation
Rob Tanner
Apr 2, 2023
Brendan Rodgers is one of the most successful managers in
Leicester City’s history, but his departure after just over four years felt inevitable in the end.
Even after leading the club to a first
FA Cup triumph, a Community Shield win and two fifth-placed
Premier League finishes (and one eighth-placed finish), Rodgers was not immune, although it seemed it was the last thing chairman Aiyawatt Srivaddhanaprabha wanted to do.
He may have been responsible for two European campaigns — they have only had six in their history — and reached the Europa Conference League semi-final last season, but the worst opening to a top-flight campaign the club has experienced since 1983 and more poor form that plunged his side back into the relegation zone with 10 games to go proved to be Rodgers’ undoing.
It was a decision the owners took on Saturday night with a heavy heart after all of Rodgers’ achievements. There was the honest assessment that they had been unable to help him refresh the squad as he had wanted because of financial fair play constraints, but they still expected more. They did not expect their Premier League status to be hanging by a thread.
What they witnessed in the 2-1 defeat away to
Crystal Palace was the catalyst. They saw a side devoid of confidence, a fanbase drained of belief, split and in some cases resigned to the drop, and they witnessed the bounce that a change of manager could have as Roy Hodgson returned to spark life into a team that had not tasted victory in 2023. Leicester will be hoping for a similar response this week as they face back-to-back home games against
Aston Villa and
Bournemouth.
Rodgers had credit in the bank that kept him in his job for longer than most had been afforded when going through difficult times. Finally, that credit ran out. Many fans had turned and when that happens, generally the club’s owners listen. Rodgers had been at the training ground on Sunday morning to pore over the Palace defeat as his future was being discussed. He soon discovered his fate.
While there was a lot of sadness when he was told, there was conviction that it was the right call. As they hoped he would turn it around, there is not a successor waiting in the wings and all options are on the table. In the meantime, first-team coach Adam Sadler and goalkeeper coach Mike Stowell have been placed in temporary charge.
James Maddison, who has excelled under Rodgers, sums up the mood after the defeat to Palace that has left them second bottom.The pressure had been building on Rodgers from sections of the fanbase even before the season kicked off.
Though there was mitigation surrounding injuries to key players, the failure to address the club’s persistent problems defending set pieces until the arrival of set-piece coach Lars Knudsen and 6ft 6in defender
Harry Souttar and an alarming tendency to run out of steam in games and concede late goals has spread into this season. Ironically, Rodgers’ last taste of action as Leicester boss was the devastating blow of Palace’s last-gasp winner at Selhurst Park. It proved to be the knockout punch, but many had seen it coming.
To those observers, the moment it all started to go wrong was the FA Cup surrender at East Midlands rivals
Nottingham Forest in February last year. But even before then, there was the 3-2 defeat at home to
Tottenham Hotspur when Rodgers’ side were 2-1 up entering stoppage time,
only to show incredible naivety to concede two Steven Bergwijn goals in the 95th and 97th minutes.
It was deja vu when they dropped two points to
Brighton & Hove Albion the following weekend. They conceded stoppage-time goals against
West Ham United,
Newcastle United and
Everton. The defensive and mental fragility that has been a feature of this season had started to emerge and Rodgers was unable to stop the rot.
Around the time of the Forest defeat, Rodgers began to talk about refreshing his squad and how the natural cycle of the group he inherited had come to an end. His frustration at the inability to bring in a central defender in that January window would become a feature of the remainder of his reign.
It was not just to add more quality to his squad, or more hunger and competition — “competition is a great coach for a player” — but to bring in fresh ears. Rodgers’ style of man-management was no longer having a positive impact on some of his squad. Previously reliable performers were playing at a level way below the standards they had set.
After three years together, things were going stale. Nine of the starting line-up at the City Ground for the 4-1 defeat to Forest had been in the first-team squad Rodgers inherited in February 2019.
Some players were unhappy with Rodgers’ comments after their FA Cup exit to Forest last season and relationships have not healed.
The club were putting the brakes on their spending under Rodgers, having registered a record net outlay of £55million ($62.8m) on five players during the summer 2021 transfer window —
Boubakary Soumare,
Patson Daka,
Jannik Vestergaard,
Ryan Bertrand (free transfer) and Ademola Lookman (loan) – without a key asset being sold that summer. That was a major contributory factor in Leicester’s recent record loss of £92.5million.
He was left needing to get more out of a group of players who were upset at his criticism after the loss to Forest. Three of those signings were earmarked to be moved on just 12 months after their arrival — Vestergaard, Soumare and Bertrand.
“That’s why a lot of these players are not top players — because they can’t sustain it,” Rodgers said after the FA Cup defeat, telling them he had been embarrassed by their display. There are players here who may have achieved everything they can.”
It was hardly motivational and without the club’s financial support in the next summer window, Rodgers had backed himself into a corner. Now he had to get a tune out of the same fiddle he had complained about.
It was a stinging rebuke and went down in the dressing room like a lead balloon. Many were now looking for the exit door. However, that door was closed to many by Leicester’s asking prices and their contracts.
Youri Tielemans, who refused to sign a new contract, was not the only one who felt he had achieved as much as he could at Leicester. Others such as
Caglar Soyuncu and
Wilfred Ndidi were now looking at opportunities elsewhere and their form has suffered.
Then there were the players Rodgers had been referring to, like Vestergaard. Rodgers had chosen the Dane as a signing following
Wesley Fofana’s injury, but the centre-back had by now been discarded and continues to be out in the cold. In a recent interview in the Danish media, he stated he did not understand why he wasn’t anywhere near Rodgers’ team. Rodgers was furious, calling Vestergaard into his office at the training ground. His signing and Bertrand have been a disaster. Soumare and
Dennis Praet were seemingly on their way out, too, while patience had worn thin with
Ayoze Perez.
When Rodgers publicly questioned Soyuncu’s commitment in training, it left no one in any doubt the Turkey international, who is one of seven players who have moved into the last year of their contracts, that his time was up at the club under Rodgers. With so many knowing they had no future at Leicester, it proved difficult to keep them motivated and committed.
Even club captain
Kasper Schmeichel was thinking of his own future. He approached Rodgers at the start of pre-season and revealed he had a tempting offer from Nice, a three-year contract Leicester seemed unwilling to match. When Leicester accepted their transfer offer, Schmeichel knew his 11 years with the club were over. He too recently claimed in an interview he did not want to leave.
Schmeichel was a leader on the pitch but could be a challenging character off it, although demanding high standards is not a bad thing and Schmeichel’s absence has been felt within a dressing room now missing its bigger characters. Rodgers was left to search for leadership elsewhere, especially when
Jonny Evans was injured.
Schmeichel was one of the highest-paid players at the club, on around £120,000 per week. His departure would help ease the club’s finances as they looked to deal with a rising wage-to-revenue ratio of 85 per cent, which was threatening their ability to conform to
UEFA’s financial fair play rules. Those wages and contracts had grown steadily during Rodgers’ tenure and the plump contracts were a major factor in the inability to move on surplus players last summer.
Schmeichel wanted to stay at Leicester before Nice’s offer of a three-year contract (Photo: Getty Images)
Rodgers was convinced
Danny Ward could step up as No 1 after being back-up to Schmeichel for nearly four years and, in May, he finally gave the Wales international his first league start since joining the club in 2018. He said it was a mutual decision with Schmeichel and Ward, but Schmeichel was unhappy his run of 149 consecutive league games had come to an end.
The mood has darkened in the squad in the past 12 months with cliques forming, particularly among the Belgium internationals, who are all close having come through similar pathways in their homeland. Praet, Tielemans and new arrival
Wout Faes all came through Anderlecht’s Purple Talent Programme. Rodgers has dropped
Timothy Castagne and Tielemans this season.
Praet’s experience is an indication of how Rodgers can quickly change his mind. Torino wanted to sign Praet again after his loan spell in Italy last season, but Rodgers had a change of heart when he realised he was not getting the full squad refresh he craved. He said Praet had a big role to play, yet he has been used sparingly. Likewise, he altered his stance over Soumare, but since the turn of the year, he hasn’t completed 90 minutes.
Rodgers had not lost the dressing room totally and players like
James Maddison, who he made captain, were fully supportive. Rodgers has had a huge impact on his career, but doubts were starting to creep into the minds of others, even the more experienced like
Jamie Vardy, who has been marginalised in recent weeks.
The manager had started making mistakes that were not happening before. Substitutions and tactical switches he would get right in previous years were now going wrong, such as when he took off Kiernan Dewsbury-Hall on the opening day of the season with his side 2-0 up against
Brentford, only for them to slip to a 2-2 draw.
Rodgers has been steadfast in his commitment to his style of play, the patient build-up from the back, looking to play through the lines, probing for the openings. It has not worked with this group of players. They are too prone to losing possession in bad areas and putting themselves under pressure. It has happened in every game this season, but Rodgers was stubborn in his belief.
After the Palace game, Rodgers looked like a man resigned to his fate, drained by the experience and devoid of solutions.
Rodgers has talked about time running out for some players but there was the impression Rodgers felt he could do little more at Leicester, especially when he discovered the purse strings had been tightened this summer unless he could move on some peripheral figures. Targets had been identified, such as winger
Cody Gakpo at PSV Eindhoven before he joined
Liverpool, but without departures, there could be no arrivals.
Rodgers has spoken about his ambitions and how he is not a manager for “maintaining” a club that is standing still but is one to build and make progress, while constantly pointing out his squad “needed help” that wasn’t forthcoming. There have been distinct echoes of the last few months of his time as manager at Liverpool, where he felt he needed more help from the board to boost his squad.
It has followed a similar track to his time at Liverpool. After an initial boost when Rodgers arrived, there was a period of success, but the decline has been just as rapid as the climb. In Leicester’s case, it has been spectacular.
Rodgers led Leicester to their first FA Cup triumph only 16 months ago (Photo: Plumb Images/Leicester City FC via Getty Images)
One source, who asked to remain anonymous to protect relationships, describes Rodgers as a “systems guy” who goes into clubs and lays out his plan, but when it stops working and needs evolving, he cannot change it, as Pep Guardiola has been able to do at
Manchester City.
His four years at Leicester is his longest period at any club.
That may be why Rodgers has appeared to be preparing for his exit and speaking like a man who has had enough, although he then insisted he was fully committed to turning around the team’s fortunes and owner Khun Top initially backed his beleaguered manager. Even when the fans started to turn, Khun Top kept faith until now. Time will tell if it has come too late.
The club’s statement said they had come to a mutual agreement with Rodgers. He will get a handsome payoff. He had over two years left to run on his contract worth around £8million a season, the highest ever given to a Leicester manager. The payments are likely to be spread over several years. His stock remains high and the memories of his achievements are still fresh in the memories of clubs who may look to make changes in the summer. He will get offers for a quick return.
As for the next Leicester manager, the priority will be to bring together a talented squad and devise a new game plan they will buy into.
Brentford’s Thomas Frank is admired internally, but it is unlikely they will get him. Likewise, Graham Potter has been the long-term favourite to succeed Rodgers. His situation at
Chelsea will be keenly watched internally at Leicester as the pressure mounts after their 2-0 defeat at home to Aston Villa.
Austrian coach Adi Hutter and former Liverpool and Newcastle United manager Rafa Benitez will be in the mix and both are available. The question will be whether they relish the battle for survival and the task of completely rebuilding a squad.
It could be the fresh start Leicester need, the players require and Rodgers may relish in time.