the met

Log in to stop seeing adverts
This page may contain links to companies such as eBay and Amazon. As an affiliate of these sites I may earn commission if you click the link and make a purchase

Status
Not open for further replies.
highland fox said:
:icon_roll I'm sorry it was an attempt at humour,I'll leave the grown ups to it.I try not to take myself or this place too seriously
Click to expand...

In that case, I excuse you. But I do wonder whether you would have attempted to make a joke of it if you lived in London or if you visited London at all regularly.

So many people see this as some kind of academic exercise which they are commenting on. Alas it was not - in the real world, it was less than 24 hours after several attempts to blow up trains had occurred and just 15 days after 3 trains and a bus were blown to pieces.
 
bocadillo said:
In that case, I excuse you. But I do wonder whether you would have attempted to make a joke of it if you lived in London or if you visited London at all regularly.
Click to expand...

I wasn't attempting to make a joke of the matter under discussion,I am well aware it is/was a serious and distressing time for everyone involved.Believe it or not I am 39 years old.
 
bocadillo said:
You should feel free to have you own defintion of 'warzone'. I was in London when deMenezes was killed; at the time I was just 3 tube stops away from the event. Bearing in mind the events of the previous day and the events that had taken place just over a fortnight earlier, I would definitely say that I was in a warzone at that time.

I am pleased that the Met police were there protecting me, even if they did make a mistake on that occasion. I am also pleased that the officer involved was allowed to carry on in his job and kill an armed robber down here in Kent a short time later.

Mistakes will be made. When the stakes are high, the mistakes will be of greater consequence - that is a matter of fact. The only way to stop making mistakes is to do nothing at all - and that would be a far greater mistake.
Click to expand...

Absolutely Boc. Most of this argument has been sterile and based on hindsight.

This was a tragedy of errors, but the circumstances of heightened public emotion and overstretch of security forces were such that the probability of something like this happening were high.

I find it odd that this case in those circumstances has attracted all this heat and hand-wringing. Much more than several other cases over the years where the pressures were nowhere near the same. Like the guy shot for carrying a table leg. Or Blair Peach. Or Kevin Gately.

Yes, I was perhaps at risk of ending up like this poor bloke. But I was certain, and remain so, that I was at a much greater risk of some lunatic blowing himself up and taking him with me - even if, in reality, the actual risk of either was extremely small.

Personally I think this trial was a mistake. Because of it the real investigation into what happened (by the IPCC) has had to be frozen. That what the forum in which real examination of the processes, misjudgements, possible culpability of individuals takes place, hopefully leading to actions to lessen the lieklihood of it happening again.
 
Last edited:
highland fox said:
I wasn't attempting to make a joke of the matter under discussion,I am well aware it is/was a serious and distressing time for everyone involved.Believe it or not I am 39 years old.
Click to expand...

You wrote that the person in charge had made up the identity of a suspect. When I challenged you on that, you said it was a joke. How was that not a joke about the matter under discussion?

You really need to make your mind up.
 
OldGit said:
Absolutely Boc. Most of this argument has been sterile and based on hindsight.

This was a tragedy of errors, but the circumstances of heightened public emotion and overstretch of security forces were such that the probability of something like this happening were high.
Click to expand...

I have to agree - I was on the tube a couple of days after the bombings and I've never experienced a feeling like it - everyone was on edge and suspicious and I've no doubt that would have played some part in the tragic death of the Brazilian. Mistakes were undoubtably made, but I don't think for a minute they were anything other than honest mistakes.
 
Melton Fox said:
I have a theory.

I try not to break the law, I think my chances of being killed by the law preventers are slim, very slim.

If I start breaking the law, I expect my chances to rise slightly.

Personally, I put it down to the fact that I try not to break the law that I am alive today, and not been killed whilst committing a mistermeanor by those that are employed to stop me.

I have in the past been naughty, and when instructed by the law enforcers to do something when I have been caught, I have promptly done it.

It is a policy I try to stick by.
Click to expand...

That is an excellent philosophy Melts and is precisely what I would do, but has no relevance to the Stockwell shooting.

JCDM had committed no misdemeanor & didn't disobey any instruction, he was sat calmly on the train when it happened.
 
Macky said:
JCDM had committed no misdemeanor & didn't disobey any instruction, he was sat calmly on the train when it happened.
Click to expand...
Well in no way can I argue that, I wasn't there. As I don't watch the news or read papers I bow to your superior knowledge on the case, and if that's true, then it's shocking.

As you pointed out, my theory didn't mention JCDM :icon_wink
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

P Pld Pts
1Liverpool1946
2Arsenal2040
3Nottm F2040
4Chelsea2036
5Newcastle2035
6Manchester C  2034
7Bournemouth2033
8Aston Villa2032
9Fulham2030
10Brighton2028
11Brentford2027
12Tottenham 2024
13Manchester U2023
14West Ham2023
15Palace2021
16Everton1917
17Wolves2016
18Ipswich2016
19Leicester2014
20Southampton206

Latest posts

Back
Top