Card Watch 2014/15

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.
Once again the reason for a booking is not clear from any of the reports that I have read. Can anybody at the game or who watched a stream give an indication why Matty James was shown a yellow card?

Edit: Thanks to Hazz for the answer to this.




Wes Morgan - 1 RED
Liverpool (h)

Morgan was suspended from the game at Villa Park

Paul Konchesky - 1 RED
Hull (a)

[COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Konchesky was suspended from today's as a result of his dismissal at Hull. He was also sent off at Villa Park; on that occasion his claim that he had been wrongfully dismissed was upheld at an independent regulatory commission hearing[/COLOR]

Jamie Vardy - 5 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Sunderland (h), Aston Villa (a), West Ham (a), Tottenham (h)

Vardy was suspended from the game at Hull, having received five cautions before the end-of-year cut-off date.

Liam Moore - 4 YELLOW
Everton (h), Arsenal (h), Newcastle (a), Southampton (a)

Ritchie de Laet - 3 YELLOW
Manchester United (h), Newcastle (a), Sunderland (h)

Jeffrey Schlupp - 3 YELLOW
Burnley (h), Liverpool (h), Aston Villa (a)

Marcin Wasilewski - 3 YELLOW
Southampton (a), Aston Villa (a), Liverpool (a) - unsporting behaviour (foul)

Dean Hammond - 2 YELLOW
Chelsea (a), Arsenal (h)

David Nugent - 2 YELLOW
Burnley (h), QPR (a)

Marc Albrighton - 2 YELLOW
Arsenal (h), QPR (a)

Leonardo Ulloa - 2 YELLOW
Newcastle (a), West Ham (a)

Danny Simpson - 2 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Hull (a)

Riyad Mahrez - 1 YELLOW
Shrewsbury (LC, h)

Esteban Cambiasso - 1 YELLOW
Aston Villa (a)

Andy King - 1 YELLOW
West Ham (a)

Matty James - 1 YELLOW
Liverpool (a) - unsporting behaviour (foul)






Total so far:
City: 2 RED, 32 YELLOW
Opponents: 2 RED, 31 YELLOW
 
Last edited:
The next 'cut-off date' is the second Sunday in April. Players receiving a tenth yellow card by then get a two-game suspension.
 
Hazzman said:
James was yellow carded retrospectively for a pull on Countinho. The ref played on, Liverpool hit a shit wide and he went back to book him (somewhat incredibly correctly).
Click to expand...


Thanks, Hazz.
 
Booking for Tom Lawrence in his City debut.

Is Vardy hoping foro a second suspension? It would seem so with him being shown the yellow card less than 2 minutes after coming off the bench.




Wes Morgan - 1 RED
Liverpool (h)

Morgan was suspended from the game at Villa Park

Paul Konchesky - 1 RED
Hull (a)

[COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Konchesky was suspended from the game at Liverpool. He was also sent off at Villa Park; on that occasion his claim that he had been wrongfully dismissed was upheld at an independent regulatory commission hearing[/COLOR]

Jamie Vardy - 6 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Sunderland (h), Aston Villa (a), West Ham (a), Tottenham (h), Newcastle (FAC, h) - unsporting behaviour (foul)

Vardy was suspended from the game at Hull, having received five cautions before the end-of-year cut-off date.

Liam Moore - 4 YELLOW
Everton (h), Arsenal (h), Newcastle (a), Southampton (a)

Ritchie de Laet - 3 YELLOW
Manchester United (h), Newcastle (a), Sunderland (h)

Jeffrey Schlupp - 3 YELLOW
Burnley (h), Liverpool (h), Aston Villa (a)

Marcin Wasilewski - 3 YELLOW
Southampton (a), Aston Villa (a), Liverpool (a)

Dean Hammond - 2 YELLOW
Chelsea (a), Arsenal (h)

David Nugent - 2 YELLOW
Burnley (h), QPR (a)

Marc Albrighton - 2 YELLOW
Arsenal (h), QPR (a)

Leonardo Ulloa - 2 YELLOW
Newcastle (a), West Ham (a)

Danny Simpson - 2 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Hull (a)

Riyad Mahrez - 1 YELLOW
Shrewsbury (LC, h)

Esteban Cambiasso - 1 YELLOW
Aston Villa (a)

Andy King - 1 YELLOW
West Ham (a)

Matty James - 1 YELLOW
Liverpool (a)

Tom Lawrence - 1 YELLOW
Newcastle (FAC, h) - unsporting behaviour (foul)






Total so far:
City: 2 RED, 34 YELLOW
Opponents: 2 RED, 34 YELLOW
 
Last edited:
bocadillo said:
Is Vardy hoping foro a second suspension? It would seem so with him being shown the yellow card less than 2 minutes after coming off the bench.
Click to expand...

I agree it was less than two minutes, but what does the 'official' stat suggest? It seemed to be within 30 seconds of him coming on!





*Yes, I do realise that 30 seconds is less than two minutes!
 
spionfox said:
I agree it was less than two minutes, but what does the 'official' stat suggest? It seemed to be within 30 seconds of him coming on!





*Yes, I do realise that 30 seconds is less than two minutes!
Click to expand...




BBC says he was on the field at 69:48 and booked at 70:35 - that's 47 seconds. The foul that brought about the booking was 4 seconds earlier.
 
bocadillo said:
BBC says he was on the field at 69:48 and booked at 70:35 - that's 47 seconds. The foul that brought about the booking was 4 seconds earlier.
Click to expand...

Thanks Boc. I thought it was quick!
 
Wes Morgan - 1 RED
Liverpool (h)

Morgan was suspended from the game at Villa Park

Paul Konchesky - 1 RED
Hull (a)

[COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Konchesky was suspended from the game at Liverpool. He was also sent off at Villa Park; on that occasion his claim that he had been wrongfully dismissed was upheld at an independent regulatory commission hearing[/COLOR]

Matty James - 1 RED
Aston Villa (h) - serious foul play

Matt James will be banned for the next three games

1 YELLOW
Liverpool (a)

Jamie Vardy - 6 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Sunderland (h), Aston Villa (a), West Ham (a), Tottenham (h), Newcastle (FAC, h)

Vardy was suspended from the game at Hull, having received five cautions before the end-of-year cut-off date.

Liam Moore - 4 YELLOW
Everton (h), Arsenal (h), Newcastle (a), Southampton (a)

Ritchie de Laet - 3 YELLOW
Manchester United (h), Newcastle (a), Sunderland (h)

Jeffrey Schlupp - 3 YELLOW
Burnley (h), Liverpool (h), Aston Villa (a)

Marcin Wasilewski - 3 YELLOW
Southampton (a), Aston Villa (a), Liverpool (a)

Dean Hammond - 3 YELLOW
Chelsea (a), Arsenal (h), Aston Villa (h) - unsporting behaviour (foul)

David Nugent - 2 YELLOW
Burnley (h), QPR (a)

Marc Albrighton - 2 YELLOW
Arsenal (h), QPR (a)

Leonardo Ulloa - 2 YELLOW
Newcastle (a), West Ham (a)

Danny Simpson - 2 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Hull (a)

Riyad Mahrez - 1 YELLOW
Shrewsbury (LC, h)

Esteban Cambiasso - 1 YELLOW
Aston Villa (a)

Andy King - 1 YELLOW
West Ham (a)

Tom Lawrence - 1 YELLOW
Newcastle (FAC, h)






Total so far:
City: 3 RED, 35 YELLOW
Opponents: 3 RED, 36 YELLOW
 
Last edited:
bocadillo said:
Wes Morgan - 1 RED
Liverpool (h)

Morgan was suspended from the game at Villa Park

Paul Konchesky - 1 RED
Hull (a)

[COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Konchesky was suspended from the game at Liverpool. He was also sent off at Villa Park; on that occasion his claim that he had been wrongfully dismissed was upheld at an independent regulatory commission hearing[/COLOR]

Matty James - 1 RED
Aston Villa (h) - serious foul play

Matt James will be banned for the next three games

1 YELLOW
Liverpool (a)

Jamie Vardy - 6 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Sunderland (h), Aston Villa (a), West Ham (a), Tottenham (h), Newcastle (FAC, h)

Vardy was suspended from the game at Hull, having received five cautions before the end-of-year cut-off date.

Liam Moore - 4 YELLOW
Everton (h), Arsenal (h), Newcastle (a), Southampton (a)

Ritchie de Laet - 3 YELLOW
Manchester United (h), Newcastle (a), Sunderland (h)

Jeffrey Schlupp - 3 YELLOW
Burnley (h), Liverpool (h), Aston Villa (a)

Marcin Wasilewski - 3 YELLOW
Southampton (a), Aston Villa (a), Liverpool (a)

Dean Hammond - 3 YELLOW
Chelsea (a), Arsenal (h), Aston Villa (h) - unsporting behaviour (foul)

David Nugent - 2 YELLOW
Burnley (h), QPR (a)

Marc Albrighton - 2 YELLOW
Arsenal (h), QPR (a)

Leonardo Ulloa - 2 YELLOW
Newcastle (a), West Ham (a)

Riyad Mahrez - 1 YELLOW
Shrewsbury (LC, h)

Danny Simpson - 1 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Hull (a)

Esteban Cambiasso - 1 YELLOW
Aston Villa (a)

Andy King - 1 YELLOW
West Ham (a)

Tom Lawrence - 1 YELLOW
Newcastle (FAC, h)






Total so far:
City: 3 RED, 35 YELLOW
Opponents: 3 RED, 36 YELLOW
Click to expand...


Was it for the foul or his reaction?
 
Matt_B said:
Was it for the foul or his reaction?
Click to expand...


The foul. If he had been sent off for his reaction it would have been termed 'violent conduct'.
 
Three games out is a big loss for us. Looked like he was hitting some form. Presume King or Cambiasso will replace James? Three games seems harsh. It wasn't that bad!!!
 
Very nasty tackle in my view, if that doesn't deserve red and a three game ban I'm not sure what does. He seemed to be holding the midfield together very well recently so a real shame.
 
jb5000 said:
Very nasty tackle in my view, if that doesn't deserve red and a three game ban I'm not sure what does. He seemed to be holding the midfield together very well recently so a real shame.
Click to expand...

I thought he was unlucky. From what I could tell on MOTD, his foot hit the upper part of the ball and was pushed up on to the Villa player's leg making it look far worse than it would otherwise have been.
 
I was pleased to finally see some aggression in our game on Saturday.

When we play teams with a soft underbelly such as Villa, we must scrap like rabid dogs. They don't like it. Too often this season, we've gone down on one knee and handed three points to less than impressive opposition. Even Wasyl seems to have put his elbows away.
 
Looked harsh to me, but also unlikely to be revoked. Not ideal, especially with Mahrez and Schlupp out as well.
 
Wes Morgan - 1 RED
Liverpool (h)
Morgan was suspended from the game at Villa Park

Paul Konchesky - 1 RED
Hull (a)
[COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Konchesky was suspended from the game at Liverpool. He was also sent off at Villa Park; on that occasion his claim that he had been wrongfully dismissed was upheld at an independent regulatory commission hearing[/COLOR]

Matty James - 1 RED
Aston Villa (h)
Matt James is serving a three game suspension; [COLOR="#a9a9a9a"]Stoke (h), Tottenham (FAC, a), Manchester Utd (a) [/COLOR]

1 YELLOW
Liverpool (a)

Jamie Vardy - 6 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Sunderland (h), Aston Villa (a), West Ham (a), Tottenham (h), Newcastle (FAC, h)
Vardy was suspended from the game at Hull, having received five cautions before the end-of-year cut-off date.

Liam Moore - 4 YELLOW
Everton (h), Arsenal (h), Newcastle (a), Southampton (a)

Marcin Wasilewski - 4 YELLOW
Southampton (a), Aston Villa (a), Liverpool (a), Stoke (h) - unsporting behaviour (foul)

Ritchie de Laet - 3 YELLOW
Manchester United (h), Newcastle (a), Sunderland (h)

Jeffrey Schlupp - 3 YELLOW
Burnley (h), Liverpool (h), Aston Villa (a)

Dean Hammond - 3 YELLOW
Chelsea (a), Arsenal (h), Aston Villa (h)

David Nugent - 2 YELLOW
Burnley (h), QPR (a)

Marc Albrighton - 2 YELLOW
Arsenal (h), QPR (a)

Leonardo Ulloa - 2 YELLOW
Newcastle (a), West Ham (a)

Danny Simpson - 2 YELLOW
Crystal Palace (a), Hull (a)

Riyad Mahrez - 1 YELLOW
Shrewsbury (LC, h)

Esteban Cambiasso - 1 YELLOW
Aston Villa (a)

Andy King - 1 YELLOW
West Ham (a)

Tom Lawrence - 1 YELLOW
Newcastle (FAC, h)






Total so far:
City: 3 RED, 36 YELLOW
Opponents: 3 RED, 36 YELLOW
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

P Pld Pts
1Liverpool1128
2Manchester C  1123
3Chelsea1119
4Arsenal1119
5Nottm F1119
6Brighton1119
7Fulham1118
8Newcastle1118
9Aston Villa1118
10Tottenham 1116
11Brentford1116
12Bournemouth1115
13Manchester U1115
14West Ham1112
15Leicester1110
16Everton1110
17Ipswich118
18Palace117
19Wolves116
20Southampton114

Latest posts

Back
Top