Cheltenham Player Ratings

[Fleetfox]

was there and done

 

[Lako42]

Seeming as Clem is dogshit I would most certainly keep it how it is.

 

[No.6 Muzzy Izzet...]

King 7 Average

I'd more or less agree with your ratings. But I thought King played much better, like Oakley, in the second half - which was the best I've seen him play. I'd still give him a 7, though.

 

[DesertFox]

King 7 Average

I may be being pedantic - I am being pedantic - but surely 5 = average

 

[SwedeFox]

I'd say 6 = average.

 

[Jeff]

I'd say 6 = average.

On a scale of 0 to 10, 5 is in the middle. 6 is above average.

But it seems that people will give a player 6 just for making it onto the pitch.

 

[Melton Fox]

That's the sytem I use. If a player does his job, nothing more, nothing less, I'll give him a 5.

If a striker doesn't score, he'll get marked down. If he misses lots of chances he'll get marked down further. If he doesn't score but has to do a lot of work in midfield because they are poor, I'll probably mark him up.

Seems some people mark a striker highly just for having the ball a lot.

 

[Durham Fox]

From what I have heard on the radio the last few games King has sounded really good and peoples ratings seem harsh, but they I wasn't there so can't really comment.

I don't agree, King is our poorest player currently. He has a decent right foot and nearly scored again yesterday from outside the box. That apart I don't rate him at all.

 

[alex]

Funny old game init? I think Andy King looks better and better...Really promising p[layer developing there for me.

 

[SwedeFox]

On a scale of 0 to 10, 5 is in the middle. 6 is above average.

But it seems that people will give a player 6 just for making it onto the pitch.

Yes, I think it has to do with Championship Manager/Football Manager where 6 is middle (if you're on the pitch for five seconds then you get a 6). So I think many ratings are based on that.

 

[Durham Fox]

Yes, I think it has to do with Championship Manager/Football Manager where 6 is middle (if you're on the pitch for five seconds then you get a 6). So I think many ratings are based on that.

and mine, 5 is below par to me

 

[Hazzman]

I may be being pedantic - I am being pedantic - but surely 5 = average

I suppose it all comes down to the Football Manager/Sun Team way of rating. He was okay and certainly did his job but in his own performance isn't his best afternoon.

His ball for Dyer's second was a peach though.

 

[Hazzman]

From what I have heard on the radio the last few games King has sounded really good and peoples ratings seem harsh, but they I wasn't there so can't really comment.

Too weak in the tackle (which will start to tell when the pitches get heavier), disappears for long spells of the game, likes passing square a lot.

 

[Matt_B]

In a team that is winning as easily as we seem to be at the minute, I don't think there can be any players playing badly.

 

[Boy Genius]

I don't agree, King is our poorest player currently. He has a decent right foot and nearly scored again yesterday from outside the box. That apart I don't rate him at all.

I have been saying this for a while now. King is very poor. It's only because we are doing well his inability is not being highlighted. Most of his passes go astray and he goes missing for long periods.

 

[beaumontfox]

I agree.
Definitely our weakest player in the first month.

 

[Melton Fox]

This is brilliant!!!!!

We are now good enough to debate if we have any shit players, and if so who's the shittest.

Much better than last season when we lording Iain Hume for scoring once in every 97 shots.

 

[DesertFox]

This is brilliant!!!!!

We are now good enough to debate if we have any shit players, and if so who's the shittest.

Much better than last season when we lording Iain Hume for scoring once in every 97 shots.

Lauding.

 

[Willlow]

Interestingly Hume scored at the weekend and it was commented on that he looked a better player playing on the wing! Who would have thought

 

[Yorkshire Vixen]

Interestingly Hume scored at the weekend and it was commented on that he looked a better player playing on the wing! Who would have thought

well he has had plenty of practice