Agreed - I think a sensible compromise would be that if the two teams are in the same division, the game goes to extra time and penalties.This game served up a textbook example of what the rule changes were designed to achieve.
Tamworth should be planning a trip to Spurs, getting probably their only chance for most players to turn out on a PL ground & probably the biggest payday in the clubs history. ...
If teams are in different divisions, however, then if it is a draw at full time - it goes to a replay - thus 'rewarding' the lower division's side for their effort along with a bit of a financial boost too.
Pity it won't happen