You have wanted a change in manager as soon as Puel was announced.
You've never given him a chance, and you probably never will.
I thought appointing him was very strange and underwhelming. I didn't feel quite the same about appointing Ranieri but that experience led me to reserve judgement and give the guy a chance.
His first couple of months were good. He inherited a team that had been positively wound up either by the departure of Shakespeare or the short tenure of Appleton. He rode that positive impetus well for a while.
However, the last few months have been very poor. Our performances and results from mid December are pretty much relegation level.
If there was any sign that this 'dip' was some short term pain for long term gain, I'd be relatively fine with it. But everything I see shows us to be getting worse overall. He's also making baffling decisions. He's sending his team out without any noticeable tactical plan and then failing to adjust to obvious issues during games.
If he wants to play a progressive, possession based game, why doesn't he pick a team that suits it? For example, instead of picking Dragovic to pass the ball from the back, he drops him for Morgan who cannot pass from the back.
He was forced into selecting Amartey who over a few games demonstrated that he was developing well and could do the role as he wanted it done. Then as soon as Simpson (who cannot do it) was fit, he was moved back in. Now we see Simpson struggle and routinely get withdrawn from matches.
Ultimately, I have loads of such reasons why I've come to the conclusion that he's no good. It wasn't a decision I came to without giving him a chance and it is a decision I'd be delighted to change if he proved me wrong. However, it is pretty bleeding obvious at the moment that he hasn't the first clue what he's doing and the players and the club are drifting slowly backwards.
We also do have some very useful evidence in his performance as manager of Southampton last season. There he had a preseason and was able to make squad changes. There he had a full season to show his skills. There he also progressively made everything worse until the point that the ownership, players and fans were all unanimously thrilled to see the back of him.