A Talking Point

Log in to stop seeing adverts

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think RK should be given a further season, and with a bit of strengthening would could and should develop a team capable of going and then subsequently staying up!! I think out the current crop of players 2-3 of them will make the grade the law of averages says so.

I dont think with MM money that we will achieve to much this season but next season we will see, that is when RK will have to stand up and counted I feel has done ok at the moment!

I disagree. Don't get me wrong I have a lot of respect for RK,a fter all he did save us last season, but the rumours of player fall-outs, bad subsitutions, and didn't he sign Josh Low?? cumulate in the fact that we need to strt fresh when MM comes in
 
Last edited:
I think RK should be given a further season, and with a bit of strengthening would could and should develop a team capable of going and then subsequently staying up!! I think out the current crop of players 2-3 of them will make the grade the law of averages says so.

I dont think with MM money that we will achieve to much this season but next season we will see, that is when RK will have to stand up and counted I feel has done ok at the moment!

RK - manager of a premiership side!!!

I suppose stranger things have happened but can't think of any.

I am assuming that MM has a bit more about him than to employ RK as manager...... youth coach position possibly? (and I am not being deliberately unkind).
 
I disagree. Don't get me wrong I have a lot of respect for RK,a fter all he did save us last season, but the rumours of player fall-outs, bad subsitutions, and didn't he sign Josh Low?? cumulate in the fact that we need to strt fresh when MM comes in

He managed to make a potential profit of £100k on Josh Low... he could get Manager of the Year for that! :icon_lol: :icon_lol:
 
RK - manager of a premiership side!!!

I suppose stranger things have happened but can't think of any.

I am assuming that MM has a bit more about him than to employ RK as manager...... youth coach position possibly? (and I am not being deliberately unkind).

After the feck ups he made at Pompey over Redknapp, I am sure he will go with someone who has a bit of nous and a track record to get us out of the division. RK's days are numbered in the managerial role. I don't expect him to be replaced by Alain Perrin...
 
I think the Dowie thing is a complete smoke screen, the manager Milan has always really rated and tried to get into Portsmouth is Alex McLeish.
 
So surely the fact City have cut their wage bill for the last few years should mean the fans start to give players a chance? :102:

I wasnt on about city, I was on about clubs in general.

We now pay peanuts, expensive peanuts mind, and look what we got....:icon_bigg
 
Something occurred to me today, I remember when I used to laugh at clubs who constantly changed manager and at their fans that couldn't understand why their team was struggling/inconsistent/not developing.

Then I realised that in the last 15 years we have had 8 Managers -

Brian Little (91-95)
Mark McGhee (95-96)
Martin O'Neill (96-2000)
Peter Taylor (2000-01)
Dave Bassett (01-02)
Micky Adams (02-04)
Craig Levein (04-06)
Rob Kelly (06-??)

And out of that 8, two were at the club for 8 years, meaning out of the remaining 7 we've had 6 managers and in the last 10 years we've had 7 managers, not including the caretakers (David Nish, Allan Evans, Gary Parker, Howard Wilkinson).

If you look at the successfully consistent teams, not just Man Utd and Arsenal but teams like Wigan, Reading, Sheffield Utd, Crewe, Birmingham, Bolton, Everton, Pompey (under Redknapp), Charlton (under Curbs) there is a common thread - consistent management.

Look at the so called under-achievers of recent times- Wolves, Leicester, Charlton (since Curbs), West Ham (apart from Pardew) Newcastle, Southampton, Leeds, West Brom, Sheffield Wednesday, Forest, Sunderland to name a few and there is another common thread, changing the manager.

Now every now and again you'll luck out and get someone like Brian Laws who will come in and start winning immediately, but chances are that if after a year the fans will boo, the board will worry and the patience starts wearing, no thought for long term development or consistency.

Most of those successful teams have 10-12 players in the squad who have in excess of 70+ appearances have learnt to play with each other and have developed in some form together. By chopping and changing managers, you naturally have to support the new man by providing funds for new players and players are chopped and changed.

So why aren't fans willing to accept time and development, supporting their young players and watching them learn rather than expecting them to have all the skills, experience, knowledge, consistency after 10 games and god forbid if their initial youthful impetutus is lost for a while....

This I think is down to fans who don't have any patience for development, young players (currently see Stearman, Fryatt, McCarthy, Logan) aren't given any time to improve, as soon as performances drop they are castigated and condemned to being 'shite' even though they might only be 19/20/21 and still learning their trade.

Look back at 85-87, we had players like Ian Andrews, Simon Morgan, Mark Venus, Mark Bright, Robert Alleyne, and even Rob Kelly coming through and who were representing their countrys at Under 21's - predicted a successful career and the spine of a Leicester team for the next 10 years. What happened?!

For those of you too young to remember, it is similar to now, fans started to boo them, call them shite (or whatever the word was at the time), their confidence crumbled and all of them left Leicester with potential unrealised.

In the case of Ian Andrews, talent always meant a club would try and rebuild the shattered confidence even those of the size of Celtic, but he never recovered. Mark Bright went onto be a top goalscorer for Crystal Palace and Sheff Wed over a long period of time.Simon Morgan went onto show his quality over a 10-12 period at Fulham and Mark Venus was one of the most consistent left backs/centre halves in the old Div 1 for over 10 -12 years. Players like Rob Kelly and Robert Alleyne never realised their potential either due to injury or application.

But what would have happened to Leicester if the fans had supported these young players through their difficult period after 20 or so 1st team games when opposition players start to work them out, or test them more and the initial confidence and form starts to ebb.

If those players had been added to Walsh, McAllister, Mauchlen, Ramsey, Smith (all of whom had the same sniped from the crowd at similar points but battled through it to a greater or lesser degree) then we might not have had to endure the poor 2nd and 3rd years of Pleat (most people forget that for the 1st year of his reign he got us playing fantastic football, inconsistent, but at times superb, before the players above were destroyed).

The similarities are similar to now, a team of young players that are developing together, getting booed when things go badly, little credit when things go well.

I'm not saying that every sacking was a bad decision, or that if Rob Kelly went in Jan/Feb that a new man couldn't improve performances and results til the end of the season, but then just as has happened for the past 3 managers the polls on internet forums will start in the summer asking inane questions such as "How long will you give A N Other?" and the most popular answer is usually Christmas and if we aren't in the play-offs then sack him.

Everytime a club goes through managers like we are currently, you can be sure its also going to be reflected in 'shite' results.

I'm not saying Rob Kelly is the messiah or that all of our young players are going to develop into Premiership stars but I don't personally believe that Leicester City fans are giving and ever have given young players, or Rob Kelly, the best chance possible of doing so.

This gets brought up time and time again, people pick out curbishley and ferguson as reasons to stick to same manager but it isnt that simple.

There is many cases where clubs have stuck with a manager and it hasnt worked out the same as has worked out but these are left out of the arguments.

Football is about results and you dont move on by taking 3 years to start winning games.

Knee jerk reactions are bad but my point is you dont keep a manager for the sake of trying to avoid changing managers.
 
This gets brought up time and time again, people pick out curbishley and ferguson as reasons to stick to same manager but it isnt that simple.

There is many cases where clubs have stuck with a manager and it hasnt worked out the same as has worked out but these are left out of the arguments.

Football is about results and you dont move on by taking 3 years to start winning games.

Knee jerk reactions are bad but my point is you dont keep a manager for the sake of trying to avoid changing managers.


exactly, and Dario Gradi usually pops up as well
 
DG's been at Crewe for 78 years and still they win feck all.

Chelsea change their manager every couple of years and are they a proven failure?

There are examples of every scenario. Simple answer is Rob Kelly aint good enough yet.

Feild Marshall Montgomory was an excellent leader of troops, but I wouldn't want to have been in his first troop if he was given the mantle way before time. He would have been dead before he got any good at the job, the same as is about to happen to Rob Kelly.
 
Last edited:
Are you seriously suggesting that Crewe are underachieving cause they haven't won anything?!
I suspect Crewe's ultimate aim is to achieve trophy wins. Because they haven't done that, then yes, by default they are underachieving
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Log in to stop seeing adverts

Championship

P Pld Pts
1Leicester4697
2Ipswich4696
3Leeds Utd4690
4Southampton4687
5West Brom4675
6Norwich City4673
7Hull City4670
8Middlesbro4669
9Coventry City4664
10Preston 4663
11Bristol City4662
12Cardiff City4662
13Millwall4659
14Swansea City4657
15Watford4656
16Sunderland4656
17Stoke City4656
18QPR4656
19Blackburn 4653
20Sheffield W4653
21Plymouth 4651
22Birmingham4650
23Huddersfield4645
24Rotherham Utd4627

Latest posts

Top