M17TT C
Well-Known Member
We sign decent players and manage to turn them into duffers.
Such as?
We sign decent players and manage to turn them into duffers.
Such as?
As an aside, there is a case that pretty much everyone NP, or to be more specific, Steve Walsh, recruits are flaky players. So many drift in and out of form like a cloud passing over the KP.
Marshall, Wood & Danns.
Marshall, Wood & Danns.
My impression is it's an age problem, not a recruitment problem.
It's a recruitment problem if you sign young players and fill your team with them.
And how have you measured their success prior to joining us?
Morgan is no better or worse than at Florist. He was poorer when he joined us because he'd spent the season out through injury.
De Laet is no better than he was the day he joined us. He's still positionally incompetent and cannot mark. Aside from that, he's an okay right back.
James hasn't improved as a player because of NP at all. He's said himself that he suffered from a lack of confidence due to injuries he'd suffered and it is only with consecutive matches that he's developed.
There is a strong case that both Drinkwater and Schmeichel have got quite a bit worse under NP. I recall watching both play prior to working for him and both impressed me more then. NP has totally destroyed Schmeichel's distribution.
King has been a better player under NP than he was under Sven. Who knows if he'd be better or worse had he never worked under NP.
Shall I list players who've turned to total shite under NP? The list is quite a bit longer than yours.
Best thread in the world and the best part is that Chris Powell aside, most potential managerial wish lists are a list of ****tards and journeymen. McLeish, Warnock, McClaren are all laughable, Holloway is just a piss take, Steve Keane, Kenny Jackett et al are not fit to lace Pearsons trainers and as for Lennon, whom was a ledge as a player, the guy is winning a league where the only serious competition has been relegated to the 3rd division, his antics on the touch line are nothing short of embarrassing, his interviews at times are unprofessional and unbecoming of a manager at a club heaped in tradition and if the rumour is true that he believes Nugent is good enough to play champions league football then I am afraid he needs locking up in the nearest loony bin.
So all in all that fine list leaves me even more convinced that our Nige should be given the opportunity to move on the remaining wasters in the squad and go again with an even more competitive squad with togetherness and belief. Automatic promotion next season I reckon. Anyway I am right and all you doubters are clearly, wrong, deluded and fools ......close thread
Aidy Boothroyd FFS
And how have you measured their success prior to joining us?
Yes and we changed tactics, Wood's form suffered as a consequence.Wood scored the same large number of goals prior to joining us as he has done for us.
Why sign anyone "just as good" if you already have someone in your squad, he would have been a good addition to our bench in recent months. He was under contract, the cost pales into insignificance based on the potential windfall of promotion.Danns I agree with but he only really had one good spell towards the end of the season under Sven, got sent off a number of times for us and given his reported high wage, there are probably just as good options available for the money.
Did I say he was? He played well at Wednesday and Megson wanted to keep him.Marshall was never on loan here..
I'm not sure if you are grasping my point or not. My opinion is that these players are not being coached or treated correctly to fulfil their potential.He is 21/22 or of the age where players at this level do not score 40-yards screamers every week otherwise they would not be in this league. I agree he has been disappointing this year but for me, he has shown he is more than worth keeping for another year and young players quite often have off seasons. Given that this was only be his very first full season as a senior pro at his own club, it would be extremely harsh and short sighted to get rid of a very highly regarded player.
It's a good job i'm bored.
Wood scored a large number of goals prior to and immediately after joining us. We're not playing to his style, simple as that (see why below), his head is down and has a face like a smacked arse most of the time. I don't think Pearson can deal with players like Wood that need confidence boosts.
Danns was the Palace player of the season prior to joining us. He should have been kept, he was a good energy player that forced errors and flew around the midfield not too dissimilar to Savage, yes not the most gifted player but Drinkwater has been a lethargic waste of a place when he came on. Not worthy of a starting spot but in my opinion he was a better option to what we ended up with warming the bench.
Marshall, played well on loan, we signed him never managed to get a large number of consistent performances from him. Sporadic performances from a player that we know can play well. An enigma, brilliant, shit, brilliant, shit. Personally I think the kid is an idiot who started to believe his own hype.
Here is my take on the Jan/Feb collapse, we played badly against Boro and Wolves but won then lost the following two league games, NP bottled it and started playing us more defensively.
Our wide men were reigned back from playing on the fullbacks, Knockeart was pulled into playing tighter to our own 18 yard, we started to ask him to pick the ball up deeper and then had to beat the winger, fullback plus any CM that closed him down. He was most effective picking the ball up on the half way line, drifting past a full back and getting towards the touchline and pulling it back or crossing. How many nice diagonal one-twos did we use to see. It becomes harder when the wingers are too deep in the first place to then get to the ball played into space by a midfielder. Dyer flattered as he made up for it with blistering pace, however too often he did all the hard work to fluff a cross.
Playing wingers deeper invited the opposition fullbacks to play higher up the pitch and put us on the back foot, our own fullbacks especially Konchesky look to have been ordered to start firing in long diagonal balls into Wood (who doesn't want them). De Laet struggles when the space in front is packed, he's a great player that can drift past players like they weren't there, but when you play deep you pack that area with players making it hard to start attacks from that position, which leads me to Schmeichel distribution, it's got worse as he bypasses the fullbacks where before Christmas Konchesky and De Laet were receiving short balls and playing football, he is guilty of trying to hard, there must have been 7/8 times in the home leg where Schmeichel played the ball straight to Almunia.
Nugent, due to our defensive set up was being asked to work the channels, he is a striker and should be played through the middle where he has has been displaced by Wood.
Beckford, as much as people dislike the guy he would have been a better prospect on the bench than Kane.
What do I think we need?
If we don't get rid of Pearson we need a coach in the style of Chris Powell, one of the lads who can mediate, as in my opinion Pearson cannot deal with players on a one to one basis. Will this happen, only if this experience has humbled Pearson.
If I was the owners i'd be seriously looking at the list of players that Pearson has identified to come in and go out.
Yes and we changed tactics, Wood's form suffered as a consequence.
Why sign anyone "just as good" if you already have someone in your squad, he would have been a good addition to our bench in recent months. He was under contract, the cost pales into insignificance based on the potential windfall of promotion.
Did I say he was? He played well at Wednesday and Megson wanted to keep him.
I'm not sure if you are grasping my point or not. My opinion is that these players are not being coached or treated correctly to fulfil their potential.
He is not on the verge of taking Palace up, they have declined steadily since he took over and I would be very surprised if they are even able to score a goal tonight, yet alone win and then beat Watford at Wembley.
P | Pld | Pts | |
1 | Liverpool | 20 | 47 |
2 | Arsenal | 21 | 43 |
3 | Nottm F | 21 | 41 |
4 | Newcastle | 21 | 38 |
5 | Chelsea | 21 | 37 |
6 | Manchester C | 21 | 35 |
7 | Aston Villa | 21 | 35 |
8 | Bournemouth | 21 | 34 |
9 | Fulham | 21 | 30 |
10 | Brentford | 21 | 28 |
11 | Brighton | 20 | 28 |
12 | West Ham | 21 | 26 |
13 | Tottenham | 21 | 24 |
14 | Palace | 21 | 24 |
15 | Manchester U | 20 | 23 |
16 | Everton | 20 | 17 |
17 | Ipswich | 20 | 16 |
18 | Wolves | 21 | 16 |
19 | Leicester | 21 | 14 |
20 | Southampton | 20 | 6 |