jb5000
Well-Known Member
As I've said elsewhere, he's been a good manager rather a great manager* so far, so we probably are splitting hairs here.
To take us up as champions at the first attempt was certainly an achievement, but quite a few teams that have come up from league one have had good first seasons in the championship (Crewe, Man C and Bristol C spring to mind immediately).
Management in league one is easier than the championship, which in turn is easier than the premiership - so of course it's an 'excuse' for his success. I suppose at the end of the day, two years just isn't long enough for a manger to make a that big a step, for me at least (though I probably wouldn't be saying that if we'd gone up!)
*And let's not start on 'legendary' manager ;-)
To take us up as champions at the first attempt was certainly an achievement, but quite a few teams that have come up from league one have had good first seasons in the championship (Crewe, Man C and Bristol C spring to mind immediately).
Management in league one is easier than the championship, which in turn is easier than the premiership - so of course it's an 'excuse' for his success. I suppose at the end of the day, two years just isn't long enough for a manger to make a that big a step, for me at least (though I probably wouldn't be saying that if we'd gone up!)
*And let's not start on 'legendary' manager ;-)