Profondo Rosso
Well-Known Member
I've got quite a bit of time for Conor Oberst, Elliott Smith, Leonard Cohen, Paul Heaton (don't laugh) and Darren Hayman as lyricists and songwriters, but none of them get close to Dylan.
I don't want to criticise Morrissey too much.. there is obviously something there as so many people really enjoy his work, but I can't say there is a single song I enjoy and looking at some of the lyrics, to me, they're just not that great.
Like I said though, it's obviously something I just don't get.
The following songs by Dylan are lyrically spot on. The 3 former probably also have a claim to be 'best song ever written':
Sad Eyed Lady of the Lowlands
Visions of Johanna
Desolation Row
Angelina
To Ramona
Of course with Dylan, you could just go on and on.
I tend to agree about Morrissey. I used to like him when I was first getting into music, but I don't tend to listen to him and don't really get anything from his lyrics any more, not that I'd call him crap though.
Agree about Cohen as well, he's one of my all-time favourites as well. I think I'd rank his debut album as pretty much my favourite ever. New Skin for the Old Ceremony is right up there too. Never really got into Bright Eyes, can't say I know enough about Heaton or Hayman.
Nick Cave, Tom Waits, Nick Drake and Neil Young are all up there for me as well, of the more modern indie artists, I tend to go more for the American artists - Jeff Mangum, Mark Kozelek, Stephin Merrit, Mark Oliver Everett etc. as well as the aforementioned Elliott Smith.
Elliott Smith isn't particularly a great lyricist, but for me he's a god a musician. Even listening his "Grand Mal" bootleg of b-sides, rarities and unreleased still, it's just incredible even how good his stuff that didn't make it to record are. Basement on a Hill is his only album that I don't absolutely love and that's still a good album.
Anyway, I agree about Visions Of Johanna as well. Depicts life's endless pursuit of perfection and the fantasy perfectly (or at least that's always been my interpretation of the lyrics - that's the thing about Dylan I guess, a lot of his lyrics are so interpretative that they can mean different thing to different people). To Ramona is amazing as well, I can't remember Angelina off the top of my head though.
Desolation Row will always be the one for me though. It's just Dylan at his angriest and most bitter and the surreal visual imagery in the song is what Dylan does better than anyone.
Oh, and have you ever heard the Bootleg Series? They're brilliant records, a mixture of live tracks, alternate versions and unreleased stuff.