Nottingham Fox
Moderator
Sheff Weds fans getting the 17:24 will get to Sheffield earlier than if they get the 17:39, so I don't see why they wouldn't use that train, if they get to the station early enough.
Maybe the BTP will decide they don't want loads of fans changing trains at Derby, so won't let them all go on the earlier train. But the 17:24 is the latest one I can get and still get home.
Yes I agree, they will get in 12 minutes earlier by changing at Derby, but I personally would much prefer to get a direct train rather than changing for the sake of 10 odd minutes. However like you say the BTP may decide what trains they do/don't get on. I think you'l be fine on your way home if i'm honest.