I'll go out on a limb here but I thought Morgan, Maguire and particularly Fuchs weren't that bad.
And has the accuracy of Kryton when heading a footballI agree.
When we changed formation though, the panic on Morgan's face for the next fifteen minutes was hilarious. He's about as comfortable in a back three as he is turning down a dessert.
What part of him not being a full back makes him forget how to cross a ball or take a corner or make a cross-field pass? Players are failing to get the basics right and this cannot be ignored because the manager makes some odd decisions.Albrighton is not a full back I have some sympathy for him, Silva has been warming the bench it will take him a few games to get going
What part of him not being a full back makes him forget how to cross a ball or take a corner or make a cross-field pass? Players are failing to get the basics right and this cannot be ignored because the manager makes some odd decisions.
We changed Silva early because he was so appalling it was making it easy for Bournemouth to carve a hole through the middle of the pitch time and time again without meeting a challenge. Taking him off was one of the few decisions Puel got right today. I don't think he started well at all, in fact he started by giving the ball away and it went downhill from there. I keep being told he is this technically gifted player but then I was told that about Gray, Slimani, Kaputska and Mendy as well and we haven't seen it from any of them either. I know I am being harsh on Silva, after all he has had limited time after a long break to get up to speed but let's not pretend he has been anything other than awful every time we have seen him and that is a cause for concern. Unlike Mendy and Gray, I think he probably may come good but I've little evidence other than a gut feeling to back up that hope.We all know that Albrighton is capable of being an excellent crosser of the ball and an excellent team player. He isn't playing well at the moment and is often being moved around the pitch into different positions. I get the impression that his confidence isn't good right now and he's probably not being well managed off the pitch as well as on it. Neither the bench nor his team mates offered him any encouragement or support when he made an error today.
Silva is a technically gifted midfielder. At the start of the game, we was a little rusty but had a clear role and made some postive touches and generally looked good. Then his manager changed the formation and gave him no clue what he was supposed to do when the Bournemouth full backs exposed gaps in our team. He has a brain though so he took it upon himself to trot round the pitch trying to get involved and largely being poor at it because is was completely disjointed from his team mates. His manager then replaces him early again no doubt doing wonders for his confidence and integration. Remember we fecked this guys career up for months and he came in not having kicked a ball in anger in eight months. We then chop and change him in and out and generally give him no chance.
He can't beat the first man with a cross. I mean, he's a footballer. It's his job. Why does his position stop him from being able to take a corner? I am as unconvinced by Puel as you but blaming every single failure of the players on him is unfair at best and ****ing ludicrous at worst.What part of moving someone into six different position in recent matches (right back, right wing back, centre midfield, left midfield, behind central striker and right midfield) enables him to give of his best?
He can't beat the first man with a cross. I mean, he's a footballer. It's his job. Why does his position stop him from being able to take a corner? I am as unconvinced by Puel as you but blaming every single failure of the players on him is unfair at best and ****ing ludicrous at worst.
Playing with the semantics doesn't work when you are doing both by absolving Albrighton and Silva of all responsibility for their own performances.I'm not blaming Puel for Albrighton delivering shit corners, I'm holding Puel responsible for it. Completely different.
Playing with the semantics doesn't work when you are doing both by absolving Albrighton and Silva of all responsibility for their own performances.
I've not absolved them...
In particular, Albrighton and Silva were both hung out to dry by their manager.
Yes, several players were poor today but none get any blame from me...
It's an odd one. I agree with you and after the Manchester City game I wanted him to be benched. He then pulls off a couple of excellent saves the game after and I remember what a brilliant shot stopper he can be. The week after that he will be back to kicking the ball out of play every two minutes and I'll be frustrated again. I go back and forth on my thoughts about him playing almost weekly!As an aside to the dreadful performace - what on earth is going on with Kasper Schmeichel?
I’ll admit to never having been a massive fan. His distribution is crap, he doesn’t command his area and he’s suspect from range. I’ve overlooked these somewhat because he is an excellent shot stopper, has been a big game player for us and also because I don’t think there are better options outside of the big clubs.
But recently he appears to have added fortnightly mental breakdowns to his performances. He’s always been mouthy but in recent weeks he has screamed at the bench for an extended period seemingly for not being allowed to go up for corners, spent numerous periods jumping about and shouting to himself and, today, at least a couple of times running up the pitch to bellow at the referee.
I’ve always thought he comes across as a bit of a knob and in recent weeks he seems to be doing his best to convert others to that view.
Interesting question. Jeff?Has a team ever been so pathetically inept at corners?
...I understand Puel has admitted he made a mistake changing formation when Amartey got injured.
I was surprised Dragovic didn't come on to play at right back.
P | Pld | Pts | |
1 | Liverpool | 11 | 28 |
2 | Manchester C | 11 | 23 |
3 | Chelsea | 11 | 19 |
4 | Arsenal | 11 | 19 |
5 | Nottm F | 11 | 19 |
6 | Brighton | 11 | 19 |
7 | Fulham | 11 | 18 |
8 | Newcastle | 11 | 18 |
9 | Aston Villa | 11 | 18 |
10 | Tottenham | 11 | 16 |
11 | Brentford | 11 | 16 |
12 | Bournemouth | 11 | 15 |
13 | Manchester U | 11 | 15 |
14 | West Ham | 11 | 12 |
15 | Leicester | 11 | 10 |
16 | Everton | 11 | 10 |
17 | Ipswich | 11 | 8 |
18 | Palace | 11 | 7 |
19 | Wolves | 11 | 6 |
20 | Southampton | 11 | 4 |